docketrouter
Clause survey / Lien waiver

Lien waiver

26 states, 26 rules, 230 authorities. Each state's card gives the rule, the trap that makes a clause drafted elsewhere fail there, and every authority with the sentences that state the rule. A state not listed is one we do not answer this family for.

26 of 26 read at the 2026-10-03 bar. A rule read at an earlier bar is not a rule that passes this one, and each card says which it is.

  1. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is the lien waiver our Alabama subcontract makes us sign enforceable?

    Alabama's construction statutes read here do not prohibit or prescribe a lien waiver. What they do say is that the paying party may condition payment on the receipt of a full release of any lien of the contractor, subcontractor, or sub-subcontractor for the amount of work being paid (Ala. Code § 8-29-3(n)), and that a party may not waive the right to receive interest before a payment is due under a contract subject to the prompt-payment chapter, although a party may waive the interest due on a late payment on or after the date the payment is due (§ 8-29-5), and that the chapter does not apply at all to residential homebuilders, to improvements to real property intended for residential purposes consisting of 16 or fewer residential units, to contracts, subcontracts or sub-subcontracts of $10,000 or less, or to contracts with the State or the local governments of Alabama (§ 8-29-7). The mechanics' and materialmen's lien itself is created by Ala. Code § 35-11-210 for work, labor, material, fixtures or machinery furnished for a building or improvement on land under a contract with the owner or the owner's agent, architect, trustee, contractor or subcontractor, on compliance with the division's requirements, and for employees of the contractor and materialmen furnishing to him the lien extends only to the amount of any unpaid balance due the contractor by the owner.

    The trap

    Two things a drafter should not read into the statute. The release § 8-29-3(n) contemplates is tied to "the amount of work being paid": nothing in the chapter blesses a release of lien rights for work not yet paid for, and nothing in it voids one either, so the waiver's own words govern. And the one waiver the chapter does restrict is of statutory interest, not of the lien: an advance waiver of interest before payment is due is outside what § 8-29-5 permits. Read § 8-29-3(n) whole before relying on it, too: the same subsection that lets the paying party condition payment on a lien release also preserves its right to withhold or not approve payment on the grounds set out in the contract, on the grounds in § 8-29-4, or otherwise for work not properly performed or payment not earned, grounds the section names and that are not stated here. Note also the ceiling in § 35-11-210, and note who it catches: the lien of an employee of the contractor, or of a person furnishing material to the contractor, reaches only the unpaid balance due the contractor from the owner, unless the supplier gave the owner the written pre-furnishing notice the section describes. A subcontractor is in the section's first clause and takes the full lien.

    as of 2026-09-17· reaches construction contracts only

    6 authorities

    • statuteAla. Code § 8-29-3enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (n) Nothing herein limits or alters the paying party’s right to withhold or not approve payment on grounds set forth in the party’s contract or the grounds set forth in Section 8-29-4 or otherwise for work not properly performed or payment not earned; rather, this section is intended only to establish a maximum amount of retainage, establish the timing for release of retainage, and provide for the payment of interest for improperly held retainage. Also, the paying party may condition payment on the receipt of a full release of any lien of the contractor, subcontractor, or sub-subcontractor for the amount of work being paid.
    • statuteAla. Code § 8-29-3enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (o) All loans and loan proceeds related to a construction project, and the disbursement and use thereof, are governed solely by the terms of the documents evidencing and securing the loan, and contractors, subcontractors, and sub-subcontractors have no lien or rights in any such loan, loan proceeds, or the disbursement or use thereof.
    • statuteAla. Code § 8-29-5enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A party may not waive the right to receive interest before a payment is due under a contract subject to this section. A party may waive the interest due on any late payment on or after the date the payment is due under Section 8-29-3.
    • statuteAla. Code § 8-29-7enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This chapter does not apply to the following: (1) Residential homebuilders. (2) Improvements to real property intended for residential purposes which consist of 16 or fewer residential units. (3) Contracts, subcontracts, or sub-subcontracts in the amount of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) or less. (4) Contracts with the state or local governments of the State of Alabama.
    • statuteAla. Code § 35-11-210enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Every mechanic, person, firm, or corporation who shall do or perform any work, or labor upon, or furnish any material, fixture, engine, boiler, waste disposal services and equipment, or machinery for any building or improvement on land, or for repairing, altering, or beautifying the same, under or by virtue of any contract with the owner or proprietor thereof, or his or her agent, architect, trustee, contractor, or subcontractor, upon complying with the provisions of this division, shall have a lien therefor on such building or improvements and on the land on which the same is situated, to the extent in ownership of all the right, title, and interest therein of the owner or proprietor, and to the extent in area of the entire lot or parcel of land in a city or town; or, if not in a city or town, of one acre in addition to the land upon which the building or improvement is situated; or, if employees of the contractor or persons furnishing material to him or her, the lien shall extend only to the amount of any unpaid balance due the contractor by the owner or proprietor, and the employees and materialmen shall also have a lien on the unpaid balance. But if the person, firm, or corporation, before furnishing any material, shall notify the owner or his or her agent in writing that certain specified material will be furnished by him or her to the contractor or subcontractor for use in the building or improvements on the land of the owner or proprietor at certain specified prices, unless the owner or proprietor or his or her agent objects thereto, the furnisher of the material shall have a lien for the full price thereof as specified in the notice to the owner or proprietor without regard to whether or not the amount of the claim for the material so furnished exceeds the unpaid balance due the contractor, unless on the notice herein provided for being given, the owner or proprietor or his or her agent shall notify the furnisher in writing before the material is used, that he or she will not be responsible for the price thereof.
    • statuteAla. Code § 35-11-210enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The notice may be given in the following form, which shall be sufficient: “To __________, owner or proprietor: “Take notice, that the undersigned is about to furnish __________, your contractor or subcontractor, certain material for the construction, or for the repairing, altering, or beautifying of a building or buildings, or improvement or improvements, on the following described property: ______________________________________________ ______________________________________________ and there will become due to the undersigned on account thereof the price of the material, for the payment of which the undersigned will claim a lien.
  2. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is this upfront lien waiver in our subcontract or purchase agreement enforceable in Alaska?

    Yes, without needing separate consideration: a real departure from states that require the waiver be given in exchange for payment. AS 34.35.117(a): "a written waiver of lien or stop-lending notice of rights created under AS 34.35.050 -- 34.35.120 signed by a claimant requires no consideration and is valid and binding." But it cannot reach ahead of the work: "A waiver permitted under this section may not relate to labor, materials, services, or equipment furnished after the date the waiver is signed by the claimant."

    The trap

    AS 34.35.117(b) is an absolute, separate carve-out that a broadly worded corporate waiver cannot reach: "An individual described in AS 34.35.120(10) may not waive right to claim a lien under AS 34.35.050 -- 34.35.120. A waiver that purports to waive the lien rights of that individual or class of individuals is void." AS 34.35.120(10) defines that protected class narrowly and specifically: "'individual' means a natural person who actually performs labor upon a building or other improvement as an employee of the owner or any contractor furnishing labor, materials, services, or equipment for the construction, alteration, or repair of a building or other improvement." A subcontractor entity signing a blanket lien waiver therefore does not, and by this statute's own words cannot, waive its own individual employee-laborers' personal lien rights: drafting the waiver more broadly does not change that outcome. The converse mistake is the one that has actually been litigated, and it is worth knowing which way it came out. In Nystrom v. Buckhorn Homes, Inc. a general contractor argued it was itself an "individual" and so could not have waived; the court held the term "does not include contractors", reasoning that "[i]f Buckhorn is an 'individual,' then all general contractors, including large, sophisticated contractors would lose the ability to waive their lien rights. Such a result is contrary to the intent of lien waivers: to help facilitate project financing." A contractor cannot borrow the laborer's shield.

    as of 2026-09-21

    6 authorities

    • statuteAS 34.35.117enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Except as provided under (b) of this section, a written waiver of lien or stop-lending notice of rights created under AS 34.35.050 — 34.35.120 signed by a claimant requires no consideration and is valid and binding. A waiver permitted under this section may not relate to labor, materials, services, or equipment furnished after the date the waiver is signed by the claimant.
    • statuteAS 34.35.117enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      An individual described in AS 34.35.120 (10) may not waive right to claim a lien under AS 34.35.050 — 34.35.120. A waiver that purports to waive the lien rights of that individual or class of individuals is void.
    • statuteAS 34.35.120enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      “individual” means a natural person who actually performs labor upon a building or other improvement as an employee of the owner or any contractor furnishing labor, materials, services, or equipment for the construction, alteration, or repair of a building or other improvement
    • case778 P.2d 1115Nystrom v. Buckhorn Homes, Inc.Alaskadecided 1989read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      The legislative history of AS 34.35.117 also supports a finding that “individual” does not include contractors.
    • case778 P.2d 1115Nystrom v. Buckhorn Homes, Inc.Alaskadecided 1989read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      If Buckhorn is an “individual,” then all general contractors, including large, sophisticated contractors would lose the ability to waive their lien rights. Such a result is contrary to the intent of lien waivers — to help facilitate project financing.
    • case778 P.2d 1115Nystrom v. Buckhorn Homes, Inc.Alaskadecided 1989read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Second, the trial court erred, as a matter of law, in construing the term “individual” in AS 34.35.120(10) to include Buckhorn and in awarding priority to Buckhorn’s lien, if valid, over Nystrom’s prior recorded deed of trust.
  3. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is this contractual lien waiver in the subcontract worth anything?

    No. An owner, direct contractor or subcontractor may not, by contract or otherwise, waive, affect or impair any other claimant's rights under the works-of-improvement part, with or without notice, and any contract term purporting to do so is VOID and unenforceable unless and until the claimant executes and delivers a waiver and release under the statutory article (Civ. Code § 8122). A claimant's waiver and release does not release the owner, construction lender or payment-bond surety unless it is in substantially the form provided in the article and signed by the claimant, and, for a conditional release, there is evidence of payment (§ 8124). Where a claimant is required to sign a waiver in exchange for a progress payment and is not in fact paid, the waiver is null, void and unenforceable unless it is in substantially the statutory form (§ 8132). The statutory forms also fix what a waiver reaches. A progress waiver, conditional or unconditional, releases rights only for labor, service, equipment and material provided "through the Through Date" and under change orders fully executed before signing, and by its own Exceptions "does not affect" retentions, extras for which the claimant has not been paid, or contract rights including rescission, abandonment, breach and "the right to recover compensation for work not compensated by the payment" (the conditional form also excepts earlier progress payments for which a conditional waiver was given and not paid) (§§ 8132, 8134). A final waiver releases the rights for the whole job and excepts only "Disputed claims for extras in the amount of" a stated sum (§§ 8136, 8138). And an unconditional waiver is null, void and unenforceable unless it is in substantially the statutory form and its "Notice to Claimant" (that the document is enforceable "EVEN IF YOU HAVE NOT BEEN PAID") is printed in at least as large a type as the largest type otherwise in the form (§§ 8134, 8138).

    The trap

    The 'waiver of lien rights' clause in the subcontract does nothing by itself: under § 8126, an oral or written statement purporting to waive, release, impair or otherwise adversely affect a lien or claim is void, and creates no estoppel, unless it is pursuant to a waiver and release under the statutory article (one form for each of four situations (conditional/unconditional x progress/final), signed by the claimant), or the claimant has actually received payment in full for the claim. Section 8130 separately preserves an accord and satisfaction concerning a good faith dispute, and an agreement settling a pending court action, where they make specific reference to the lien or claim. One release in the article escapes the forms entirely: under § 8128 a claimant may reduce the amount of, or release in its entirety, a stop payment notice, and that reduction or release need only be in writing and "may be given in a form other than a waiver and release form provided in this article", so a non-form writing that releases a stop payment notice does release it, to the extent of the reduction, while leaving every other right of the claimant alone. The second trap is the check: a conditional release is not effective without evidence of payment, which means a claimant's endorsement on a paid joint-payee check or a written acknowledgment of payment, so a signed conditional release sitting in the file with an unpaid check releases nothing. The third trap is reading the signed form for more than it says: a progress waiver in the statutory form never releases retention, unpaid extras or the claimant's contract claims for uncompensated work, because the form's printed Exceptions keep them out, so an owner holding a stack of executed progress waivers still faces the retention claim and the breach claim, and only the FINAL forms close the job.

    as of 2026-09-16· reaches construction contracts only

    10 authorities

    • statuteCal. Civ. Code § 8122enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      An owner, direct contractor, or subcontractor may not, by contract or otherwise, waive, affect, or impair any other claimant’s rights under this part, whether with or without notice, and any term of a contract that purports to do so is void and unenforceable unless and until the claimant executes and delivers a waiver and release under this article.
    • statuteCal. Civ. Code § 8124enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A claimant’s waiver and release does not release the owner, construction lender, or surety on a payment bond from a lien or claim unless both of the following conditions are satisfied: (a) The waiver and release is in substantially the form provided in this article and is signed by the claimant. (b) If the release is a conditional release, there is evidence of payment to the claimant. Evidence of payment may be either of the following: (1) The claimant’s endorsement on a single or joint payee check that has been paid by the financial institution on which it was drawn. (2) Written acknowledgment of payment by the claimant.
    • statuteCal. Civ. Code § 8132enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If a claimant is required to execute a waiver and release in exchange for, or in order to induce payment of, a progress payment and the claimant is not, in fact, paid in exchange for the waiver and release or a single payee check or joint payee check is given in exchange for the waiver and release, the waiver and release shall be null, void, and unenforceable unless it is in substantially the following form: CONDITIONAL WAIVER AND RELEASE ON PROGRESS PAYMENT NOTICE: THIS DOCUMENT WAIVES THE CLAIMANT’S LIEN, STOP PAYMENT NOTICE, AND PAYMENT BOND RIGHTS EFFECTIVE ON RECEIPT OF PAYMENT. A PERSON SHOULD NOT RELY ON THIS DOCUMENT UNLESS SATISFIED THAT THE CLAIMANT HAS RECEIVED PAYMENT. Identifying Information Name of Claimant: Name of Customer: Job Location: Owner: Through Date: Conditional Waiver and Release This document waives and releases lien, stop payment notice, and payment bond rights the claimant has for labor and service provided, and equipment and material delivered, to the customer on this job through the Through Date of this document. Rights based upon labor or service provided, or equipment or material delivered, pursuant to a written change order that has been fully executed by the parties prior to the date that this document is signed by the claimant, are waived and released by this document, unless listed as an Exception below. This document is effective only on the claimant’s receipt of payment from the financial institution on which the following check is drawn: Maker of Check: Amount of Check: $ Check Payable to: Exceptions This document does not affect any of the following: (1) Retentions. (2) Extras for which the claimant has not received payment. (3) The following progress payments for which the claimant has previously given a conditional waiver and release but has not received payment: Date(s) of waiver and release: Amount(s) of unpaid progress payment(s): $ (4) Contract rights, including (A) a right based on rescission, abandonment, or breach of contract, and (B) the right to recover compensation for work not compensated by the payment. Signature Claimant’s Signature: Claimant’s Title: Date of Signature:
    • statuteCal. Civ. Code § 8126enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      An oral or written statement purporting to waive, release, impair or otherwise adversely affect a lien or claim is void and unenforceable and does not create an estoppel or impairment of the lien or claim unless either of the following conditions is satisfied: (a) The statement is pursuant to a waiver and release under this article. (b) The claimant has actually received payment in full for the claim.
    • statuteCal. Civ. Code § 8130enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This article does not affect the enforceability of either an accord and satisfaction concerning a good faith dispute or an agreement made in settlement of an action pending in court if the accord and satisfaction or agreement and settlement make specific reference to the lien or claim.
    • statuteCal. Civ. Code § 8134enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If the claimant is required to execute a waiver and release in exchange for, or in order to induce payment of, a progress payment and the claimant asserts in the waiver that the claimant has, in fact, been paid the progress payment, the waiver and release shall be null, void, and unenforceable unless it is in substantially the following form, with the text of the “Notice to Claimant” in at least as large a type as the largest type otherwise in the form: UNCONDITIONAL WAIVER AND RELEASE ON PROGRESS PAYMENT NOTICE TO CLAIMANT: THIS DOCUMENT WAIVES AND RELEASES LIEN, STOP PAYMENT NOTICE, AND PAYMENT BOND RIGHTS UNCONDITIONALLY AND STATES THAT YOU HAVE BEEN PAID FOR GIVING UP THOSE RIGHTS. THIS DOCUMENT IS ENFORCEABLE AGAINST YOU IF YOU SIGN IT, EVEN IF YOU HAVE NOT BEEN PAID. IF YOU HAVE NOT BEEN PAID, USE A CONDITIONAL WAIVER AND RELEASE FORM. Identifying Information Name of Claimant: Name of Customer: Job Location: Owner: Through Date: Unconditional Waiver and Release This document waives and releases lien, stop payment notice, and payment bond rights the claimant has for labor and service provided, and equipment and material delivered, to the customer on this job through the Through Date of this document. Rights based upon labor or service provided, or equipment or material delivered, pursuant to a written change order that has been fully executed by the parties prior to the date that this document is signed by the claimant, are waived and released by this document, unless listed as an Exception below. The claimant has received the following progress payment: $ Exceptions This document does not affect any of the following: (1) Retentions. (2) Extras for which the claimant has not received payment. (3) Contract rights, including (A) a right based on rescission, abandonment, or breach of contract, and (B) the right to recover compensation for work not compensated by the payment. Signature Claimant’s Signature: Claimant’s Title: Date of Signature:
    • statuteCal. Civ. Code § 8136enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If the claimant is required to execute a waiver and release in exchange for, or in order to induce payment of, a final payment and the claimant is not, in fact, paid in exchange for the waiver and release or a single payee check or joint payee check is given in exchange for the waiver and release, the waiver and release shall be null, void, and unenforceable unless it is in substantially the following form: CONDITIONAL WAIVER AND RELEASE ON FINAL PAYMENT NOTICE: THIS DOCUMENT WAIVES THE CLAIMANT’S LIEN, STOP PAYMENT NOTICE, AND PAYMENT BOND RIGHTS EFFECTIVE ON RECEIPT OF PAYMENT. A PERSON SHOULD NOT RELY ON THIS DOCUMENT UNLESS SATISFIED THAT THE CLAIMANT HAS RECEIVED PAYMENT. Identifying Information Name of Claimant: Name of Customer: Job Location: Owner: Conditional Waiver and Release This document waives and releases lien, stop payment notice, and payment bond rights the claimant has for labor and service provided, and equipment and material delivered, to the customer on this job. Rights based upon labor or service provided, or equipment or material delivered, pursuant to a written change order that has been fully executed by the parties prior to the date that this document is signed by the claimant, are waived and released by this document, unless listed as an Exception below. This document is effective only on the claimant’s receipt of payment from the financial institution on which the following check is drawn: Maker of Check: Amount of Check: $ Check Payable to: Exceptions This document does not affect any of the following: Disputed claims for extras in the amount of: $ Signature Claimant’s Signature: Claimant’s Title: Date of Signature:
    • statuteCal. Civ. Code § 8138enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If the claimant is required to execute a waiver and release in exchange for, or in order to induce payment of, a final payment and the claimant asserts in the waiver that the claimant has, in fact, been paid the final payment, the waiver and release shall be null, void, and unenforceable unless it is in substantially the following form, with the text of the “Notice to Claimant” in at least as large a type as the largest type otherwise in the form: UNCONDITIONAL WAIVER AND RELEASE ON FINAL PAYMENT NOTICE TO CLAIMANT: THIS DOCUMENT WAIVES AND RELEASES LIEN, STOP PAYMENT NOTICE, AND PAYMENT BOND RIGHTS UNCONDITIONALLY AND STATES THAT YOU HAVE BEEN PAID FOR GIVING UP THOSE RIGHTS. THIS DOCUMENT IS ENFORCEABLE AGAINST YOU IF YOU SIGN IT, EVEN IF YOU HAVE NOT BEEN PAID. IF YOU HAVE NOT BEEN PAID, USE A CONDITIONAL WAIVER AND RELEASE FORM. Identifying Information Name of Claimant: Name of Customer: Job Location: Owner: Unconditional Waiver and Release This document waives and releases lien, stop payment notice, and payment bond rights the claimant has for all labor and service provided, and equipment and material delivered, to the customer on this job. Rights based upon labor or service provided, or equipment or material delivered, pursuant to a written change order that has been fully executed by the parties prior to the date that this document is signed by the claimant, are waived and released by this document, unless listed as an Exception below. The claimant has been paid in full. Exceptions This document does not affect the following: Disputed claims for extras in the amount of: $ Signature Claimant’s Signature: Claimant’s Title: Date of Signature:
    • statuteCal. Civ. Code § 8120enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The provisions of this chapter apply to a work of improvement governed by this part.
    • statuteCal. Civ. Code § 8128enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (a) A claimant may reduce the amount of, or release in its entirety, a stop payment notice. The reduction or release shall be in writing and may be given in a form other than a waiver and release form provided in this article.
  4. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Can a Connecticut construction contract or periodic lien waiver give up mechanic's lien or payment bond rights in advance?

    No, for work not yet performed and paid for. Any provision in a construction contract, or any periodic lien waiver issued under one, that purports to waive or release a contractor's, subcontractor's or supplier's right to claim a mechanic's lien or make a claim against a payment bond for services, labor or materials which have not yet been performed and paid for is void and of no effect (§ 42-158l(a)). Subordination of a mechanic's lien to a mortgage or security interest, and enforcement of an agreement to subordinate, are not prohibited by this section (§ 42-158l(b)).

    The trap

    The statute voids only waivers for work not yet performed AND paid for, so a waiver limited to paid work is outside it. And it applies only to a construction contract as defined in § 42-158i, a contract for construction, renovation or rehabilitation in this state on or after October 1, 1999: it does not reach public works contracts with the state, the United States, another state or a municipality, HUD-funded or HUD-insured projects, owner-contractor contracts of $25,000 or less (and their subcontracts), or buildings for residential occupancy of four or fewer units.

    as of 2026-09-16

    3 authorities

    • statuteConn. Gen. Stat. § 42-158lenactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Any provision in a construction contract or any periodic lien waiver issued pursuant to a construction contract that purports to waive or release the right of a contractor, subcontractor or supplier engaged to perform services, perform labor or furnish materials under the construction contract to (1) claim a mechanic's lien, or (2) make a claim against a payment bond, for services, labor or materials which have not yet been performed and paid for shall be void and of no effect.
    • statuteConn. Gen. Stat. § 42-158ienactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      As used in sections 42-158i to 42-158n , inclusive, unless the context otherwise requires: (1) “Owner” means any individual, corporation, nonprofit corporation, partnership, limited partnership, limited liability company or other business entity that is the owner of record or lessee of real property upon which construction, renovation or rehabilitation is to be or is being performed pursuant to a construction contract regarding such real property. (2) “Construction contract” or “contract” means any contract for the construction, renovation or rehabilitation in this state on or after October 1, 1999, including any improvements to real property that are associated with such construction, renovation or rehabilitation, or any subcontract for construction, renovation or rehabilitation between an owner and a contractor, or between a contractor and a subcontractor or subcontractors, or between a subcontractor and any other subcontractor. “Construction contract” or “contract” does not include (A) any public works or other building contract entered into with this state, the United States, any other state, and any municipality or other political subdivision of this state or any other state, (B) a contract or project funded or insured by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development, (C) a contract between an owner and a contractor for an amount of twenty-five thousand dollars or less or a subcontract which results from such a contract, or (D) a contract for a building intended for residential occupancy containing four or less units.
    • statuteConn. Gen. Stat. § 42-158lenactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Notwithstanding any provision of subsection (a) of this section, this section shall not be construed to prohibit (1) the subordination of a mechanic's lien to the lien of a mortgage or security interest, or (2) the enforcement of an agreement to subordinate a mechanic's lien to the lien of a mortgage or security interest.
  5. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is a no-lien clause or an up-front lien waiver enforceable in a Delaware construction contract?

    No. Notwithstanding any other law, any contract, agreement or understanding by which the right to file or enforce a mechanics' lien under 25 Del. C. ch. 27 is waived is void as against public policy and wholly unenforceable. Two things are preserved: a written waiver executed and delivered by a contractor, subcontractor, material supplier or labourer SIMULTANEOUSLY WITH OR AFTER payment for the labour performed or materials supplied, and a written agreement to subordinate, release or satisfy a lien made after a statement of claim has been filed. Granting credit or taking notes or other securities is not itself a waiver unless received as payment or the lien is expressly waived; its only effect is to postpone the lien until the agreed time expires.

    The trap

    Timing is the whole rule. The industry habit of collecting a lien waiver with the pay application, before the money moves, fails in Delaware, because the statute saves only a waiver executed simultaneously with or after payment. A subordination or release negotiated after a statement of claim has been filed is fine. And the section that § 2706(b) expressly refuses to touch is the one that can defeat the lien outright: under § 2707 no lien attaches to land or a structure 'used solely as a residence of said owner' once the owner has made full or final payment to the contractor in good faith, so on a residential job the waiver question can be moot. A related trap sits one chapter over: 25 Del. C. § 2614 makes a broker's advance waiver of a broker's lien void too, but not on the same terms. It saves only a waiver given after the broker has 'first received full payment', with no simultaneous-with-payment saving and no post-claim subordination.

    as of 2026-09-16· reaches construction contracts only

    4 authorities

    • statute25 Del. C. § 2706enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (b) Notwithstanding the provisions of any other law, except as provided in this subsection: Any contract, any agreement or understanding whereby the right to file or enforce any lien created under this chapter is waived, shall be void as against public policy and wholly unenforceable. This section shall not preclude a requirement for a written waiver of the right to file a mechanics’ lien executed and delivered by a contractor, subcontractor, material supplier or laborer simultaneously with or after payment for the labor performed or the materials supplied has been made to such contractor, subcontractor, material supplier or laborer nor shall this section be applicable to a written agreement to subordinate, release or satisfy all or part of such lien made after a statement of claim has been filed under this chapter. Nothing in this subsection shall amend, exempt, limit or qualify the provisions of § 2707 of this title.
    • statute25 Del. C. § 2614enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      An agreement by a broker to waive its right to a broker’s lien without having first received full payment is against public policy, void, and unenforceable.
    • statute25 Del. C. § 2706enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (a) Persons entitled to avail themselves of the lien provided for in this chapter shall not be considered as waiving the same by granting a credit or receiving notes or other securities, unless the same be received as payment or the lien expressly waived, but the sole effect thereof shall be to prevent such persons from availing themselves of the liens provided for in this chapter until the expiration of the time agreed upon.
    • statute25 Del. C. § 2707enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      No lien shall be obtained under this chapter upon the lands, structure, or both, of any owner which is used solely as a residence of said owner when the owner has made either full or final payment to the contractor, in good faith, with whom the owner contracted for the construction, erection, building, improvement, alteration or repair thereof. Prior to or simultaneous with the receipt of any full or final payment by the contractor, the contractor must provide the owner either: (1) A notarized, verified written certification that the contractor has paid in full for all labor performed and materials furnished to the date of such full or final payment in or for such construction, erection, building, improvement, alteration or repair or (2) A written release of mechanics’ liens signed by all persons who would otherwise be entitled to avail themselves of the provisions of this chapter, containing a notarized, verified certification signed by the contractor that all of the persons signing the release constitute all of the persons who have furnished materials and performed labor in and for the construction, erection, building, improvement, alteration and repair to the date of the release and who would be entitled otherwise to file mechanics’ liens claims. Failure of the contractor to provide the owner a written certification or a release of mechanics’ liens at such time shall constitute sufficient cause for the immediate suspension, revocation or cancellation of the contractor’s occupational and business licenses. If the owner has not made full payment in good faith to such contractor, the lien may be obtained in accordance with this chapter, but it shall be a lien only to the extent of the balance of the payment due such contractor, which balance or portion shall be payable pro rata among the claimants who perfect liens. Payments made to the contractor by the owner after service of process, as provided in § 2715 of this title, shall not be deemed to be “in good faith.”
  6. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is this lien waiver enforceable, and can the owner make us sign its own form?

    A right to claim a construction lien may not be waived in advance, and any advance waiver is unenforceable; a lien right may be waived only to the extent of labor, services or materials actually furnished (Fla. Stat. § 713.20(2)). Section 713.20(4)-(5) supplies statutory progress-payment and final-payment waiver forms, and § 713.20(6) forbids requiring a lienor to furnish a waiver different from those forms. A lienor who signs a waiver in exchange for a check may condition it on payment of the check, but the same subsection gives the other side something back: where no payment bond protects the owner, the owner may withhold from any payment to the contractor the amount of the unpaid check until the condition is satisfied (§ 713.20(7)). Two more subsections frame all of this. Accepting an unsecured note for the amount demanded is not a waiver of the lien unless it is expressly so agreed in writing, and does not affect the filing periods under § 713.06(2) or § 713.08 (§ 713.20(1)); and § 713.20(3) lets a lienor waive, release or satisfy any part of the lien at any time, whether by amount, by work done through a certain date subject to exceptions specified at the time of release, or by parcel.

    The trap

    Subsections (6) and (8) point in opposite directions and (8) is the one that bites. Nobody may REQUIRE a lienor to sign a non-statutory waiver, but § 713.20(8) provides that a waiver or release that is not substantially similar to the statutory forms 'is enforceable in accordance with the terms of the lien waiver or lien release'. So the custom, broader waiver you should have refused binds you by its own words once signed, except that no form can waive lien rights for labor, services or materials not yet furnished: § 713.20(2)'s advance-waiver bar is unqualified. Note what the statutory progress-payment form in subsection (4) carries that a custom form will quietly drop: 'This waiver and release does not cover any retention or labor, services, or materials furnished after the date specified.' Sign the owner's form instead and you lose that sentence. On a public job the parallel question for the payment bond has its own answer: asked whether a subcontractor on a public works project could lawfully waive its rights to the contractor's bond required by §§ 255.05 and 337.18, the Florida Supreme Court answered the certified question in the negative and approved the Second District, a unanimous court reasoning that although the legislature wrote exemptions into § 255.05 it chose not to allow unrestricted waiver.

    as of 2026-09-17· reaches construction contracts only

    11 authorities

    • statuteFla. Stat. § 713.20enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (1) The acceptance by the lienor of an unsecured note for all or any part of the amount of his or her demand shall not constitute a waiver of his or her lien therefor unless expressly so agreed in writing, nor shall it in any way affect the period for filing the notice under s. 713.06(2), or the claim of lien under s. 713.08.
    • statuteFla. Stat. § 713.20enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (2) A right to claim a lien may not be waived in advance. A lien right may be waived only to the extent of labor, services, or materials furnished. Any waiver of a right to claim a lien that is made in advance is unenforceable.
    • statuteFla. Stat. § 713.20enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (3) Any person may at any time waive, release, or satisfy any part of his or her lien under this part, either as to the amount due for labor, services, or materials furnished or for labor, services, or materials furnished through a certain date subject to exceptions specified at the time of release, or as to any part or parcel of the real property.
    • statuteFla. Stat. § 713.20enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (4) When a lienor is required to execute a waiver or release of lien in exchange for, or to induce payment of, a progress payment, the waiver or release may be in substantially the following form:WAIVER AND RELEASE OF LIEN UPON PROGRESS PAYMENT The undersigned lienor, in consideration of the sum of $ , hereby waives and releases its lien and right to claim a lien for labor, services, or materials furnished through (insert date) to (insert the name of your customer) on the job of (insert the name of the owner) to the following property: (description of property) This waiver and release does not cover any retention or labor, services, or materials furnished after the date specified.
    • statuteFla. Stat. § 713.20enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (5) When a lienor is required to execute a waiver or release of lien in exchange for, or to induce payment of, the final payment, the waiver and release may be in substantially the following form:WAIVER AND RELEASE OF LIEN UPON FINAL PAYMENT The undersigned lienor, in consideration of the final payment in the amount of $ , hereby waives and releases its lien and right to claim a lien for labor, services, or materials furnished to (insert the name of your customer) on the job of (insert the name of the owner) to the following described property: (description of property)
    • statuteFla. Stat. § 713.20enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (6) A person may not require a lienor to furnish a lien waiver or release of lien that is different from the forms in subsection (4) or subsection (5).
    • statuteFla. Stat. § 713.20enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (7) A lienor who executes a lien waiver and release in exchange for a check may condition the waiver and release on payment of the check. However, in the absence of a payment bond protecting the owner, the owner may withhold from any payment to the contractor the amount of any such unpaid check until any such condition is satisfied.
    • statuteFla. Stat. § 713.20enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (8) A lien waiver or lien release that is not substantially similar to the forms in subsections (4) and (5) is enforceable in accordance with the terms of the lien waiver or lien release.
    • case542 So. 2d 957American Cas. Co. v. Coastal Caisson Drill Co.Fla.decided 1989-03-16read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Section 713.20(2) formerly provided that anyone, other than a laborer, could waive a mechanics' lien at any time. The legislature recently amended this statute, however, and it now provides that a right to claim a lien may not be waived in advance. Ch. 88-397, Laws of Fla. Although not controlling in this case, the amendment illustrates a legislative policy against waiver.
    • case542 So. 2d 957American Cas. Co. v. Coastal Caisson Drill Co.Fla.decided 1989-03-16read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      MAY A SUBCONTRACTOR FURNISHING LABOR, SERVICES OR EQUIPMENT WORTH OVER $200,000 ON A PUBLIC WORKS PROJECT LAWFULLY WAIVE ITS RIGHTS TO THE CONTRACTOR'S BOND REQUIRED PURSUANT TO SECTIONS 255.05 AND 337.18, FLORIDA STATUTES (1985)? We have jurisdiction. Art. V, § 3(b)(4), Fla. Const. We answer the certified question in the negative.
    • case542 So. 2d 957American Cas. Co. v. Coastal Caisson Drill Co.Fla.decided 1989-03-16read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Moreover, even though the legislature provided certain exemptions, which do not apply here, from the bond requirement in *959 section 255.05, [2] it chose not to allow unrestricted waiver. We hereby answer the certified question in the negative and approve the decision of the Second District Court of Appeal. It is so ordered. EHRLICH, C.J., and OVERTON, SHAW, BARKETT, GRIMES and KOGAN, JJ., concur.
  7. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is this up-front 'contractor waives all lien rights' clause good in Illinois?

    No. Under 770 ILCS 60/1(d) an agreement to waive any right to enforce or claim any lien under the Mechanics Lien Act, or an agreement to subordinate the lien, where the agreement is in anticipation of and in consideration for the awarding of a contract or subcontract, express or implied, to perform work or supply materials for an improvement upon real property, is against public policy and unenforceable. The Act states the mirror rule too: where a contract provision's legal effect is that no lien may be filed or the lien is subordinated, and the provision "is not prohibited by this Act, such provision shall be binding if made as part of an agreement not prohibited by this Act" (770 ILCS 60/21(b)), so a waiver or subordination given outside § 1(d)'s in-anticipation-of-award setting holds. A pay-if-paid or pay-when-paid term is no defence to a subcontractor's or supplier's lien claim (§ 21(e)). And where a filed claim for lien is paid with the cost of filing, or suit to enforce it is not instituted after demand within the time the Act limits, the person who filed it must acknowledge satisfaction or release in writing on the written demand of the owner, lienor or any person interested in the real estate, and on neglect to do so for 10 days owes the owner $2,500 plus costs and reasonable attorney's fees (§ 35(a)).

    The trap

    The vice is the timing and the consideration, not the words: what § 1(d) reaches is an agreement "in anticipation of and in consideration for the awarding of a contract or subcontract", so the same sentence in the prime contract signed to WIN the work is, in the section's own words, against public policy and unenforceable, while a waiver or release given later for work already done is outside the words that void it. Read the carve-out for what it is, though. Section 1(d)'s own saving is narrower than a progress-payment waiver: it preserves "release of lien under subsection (b) of Section 35", and § 35(b) is the recording provision. A satisfaction or release may be filed with the recorder of deeds where the claim for lien was filed and once filed "shall forever thereafter discharge and release the claim for lien and shall bar all actions brought or to be brought thereupon", which is the back end of § 35(a)'s duty to acknowledge satisfaction of a FILED claim that has been paid. Nothing in § 1(d) names a progress-payment waiver. The subordination half catches the clause drafters use instead of a waiver (agreeing in advance that the lien sits behind the construction lender) with one exception in the statute: subordination to a mortgage securing a construction loan is permitted if agreed after more than 50% of the loan has been disbursed to fund improvements. Section 1(c) adds that taking additional security is not a waiver unless made one by express agreement and not prohibited by the Act.

    as of 2026-09-17· reaches construction contracts only

    7 authorities

    • statute770 ILCS 60/1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (d) An agreement to waive any right to enforce or claim any lien under this Act, or an agreement to subordinate the lien, where the agreement is in anticipation of and in consideration for the awarding of a contract or subcontract, either express or implied, to perform work or supply materials for an improvement upon real property is against public policy and unenforceable.
    • statute770 ILCS 60/1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This Section does not prohibit release of lien under subsection (b) of Section 35 of this Act, nor does it prohibit an agreement to subordinate a mechanics lien to a mortgage lien that secures a construction loan if that agreement is made after more than 50% of the loan has been disbursed to fund improvements to the property.
    • statute770 ILCS 60/1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (c) The taking of additional security by the contractor or sub-contractor is not a waiver of any right of lien which he may have by virtue of this Act, unless made a waiver by express agreement of the parties and the waiver is not prohibited by this Act.
    • statute770 ILCS 60/21enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (b) If the legal effect of a provision in any contract between the owner and contractor or contractor and subcontractor is that no lien or claim may be filed or maintained, or that such contractor's lien shall be subordinated to the interests of any other party, and the provision is not prohibited by this Act, such provision shall be binding if made as part of an agreement not prohibited by this Act.
    • statute770 ILCS 60/21enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (e) Any provision in a contract, agreement, or understanding, when payment from a contractor to a subcontractor or supplier is conditioned upon receipt of the payment from any other party including a private or public owner, shall not be a defense by the party responsible for payment to a claim brought under Section 21, 22, 23, or 28 of this Act against the party.
    • statute770 ILCS 60/35enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (a) Whenever a claim for lien has been filed with the recorder of deeds, either by the contractor or sub-contractor, and is paid with cost of filing same, or where there is a failure to institute suit to enforce the same after demand as provided in the preceding Section within the time by this Act limited the person filing the same or some one by him duly authorized in writing so to do, shall acknowledge satisfaction or release thereof, in writing, on written demand of the owner, lienor, or any person interested in the real estate, or his or her agent or attorney, and on neglect to do so for 10 days after such written demand he or she shall be liable to the owner for the sum of $2,500, which may be recovered in a civil action together with the costs and the reasonable attorney's fees of the owner, lienor, or other person interested in the real estate, or his or her agent or attorney incurred in bringing such action.
    • statute770 ILCS 60/35enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (b) Such a satisfaction or release of lien may be filed with the recorder of deeds in whose office the claim for lien had been filed and when so filed shall forever thereafter discharge and release the claim for lien and shall bar all actions brought or to be brought thereupon.
  8. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is the lien waiver our Iowa subcontract makes us sign enforceable?

    Nothing read in Iowa's mechanics' lien chapter voids or prescribes a lien waiver, and this rule records that rather than treating the silence as permission. Chapter 572 creates the lien: every person who furnishes material or labour for, or performs labour upon, a building or land for improvement, alteration or repair, by virtue of a contract with the owner, owner-builder, general contractor or subcontractor, has a lien upon the building or improvement and the owner's land, to secure payment for the material or labour (Iowa Code § 572.2(1)). The only waiver the chapter's read sections describe is one the owner may insist on before paying: on commercial construction, the owner is not required to pay the general contractor for work done or material furnished until ninety days after completion unless the general contractor furnishes the owner either receipts and waivers of claims for mechanics' liens signed by all persons who furnished material or performed labour, or a bond holding the owner harmless from loss by reason of subcontractors' liens (§ 572.33A(1)). The lien is not for everyone who builds: "An owner-builder is not entitled to a lien under this chapter as to work the owner-builder performs, or is contractually obligated to perform, prior to transferring title to the buyer" (§ 572.2(3)), and § 572.1(9) defines an owner-builder as the titleholder of record who furnishes material or performs labour, or contracts with a subcontractor to do so, "and who offers or intends to offer to sell the owner-builder’s property without occupying or using the structures, properties, developments, or improvements for a period of more than one year from the date the structure, property, development, or improvement is substantially completed or abandoned."

    The trap

    Iowa, unlike several states, has no section in the mechanics' lien chapter declaring an advance lien waiver void or unenforceable, so for a mechanics' lien the waiver's own words govern and the fight is one of general contract law rather than one protected by statute. Iowa does know how to void a lien waiver when it means to, which is why the absence here is worth noticing rather than assuming: for the commodity production contract lien of chapter 579B, § 579B.6 provides that "A waiver of a right created by this chapter, including but not limited to a waiver of the right to file a lien pursuant to this chapter, is void and unenforceable", severable from the rest of the contract. That section protects a contract producer of livestock, raw milk or a crop, not a construction subcontractor. Two limits that do come from the text: § 572.33A applies only to commercial construction properties, and the waiver it contemplates is a document the general contractor gives the OWNER so that payment can be released: it is not authority for what a subcontract may demand of a subcontractor. Whether an Iowa court will enforce a waiver signed before payment is received, and how a conditional waiver differs from an unconditional one, is not established by anything in this rule.

    as of 2026-09-19· reaches construction contracts only

    6 authorities

    • statuteIowa Code § 572.2enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Every person who furnishes any material or labor for, or performs any labor upon, any building or land for improvement, alteration, or repair thereof, including those engaged in the construction or repair of any work of internal or external improvement, and those engaged in grading, sodding, installing nursery stock, landscaping, sidewalk building, fencing on any land or lot, by virtue of any contract with the owner, owner-builder, general contractor, or subcontractor shall have a lien upon such building or improvement, and land belonging to the owner on which the same is situated or upon the land or lot so graded, landscaped, fenced, or otherwise improved, altered, or repaired, to secure payment for the material or labor furnished or labor performed.
    • statuteIowa Code § 572.33Aenactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      An owner of a building, land, or improvement upon which a mechanic’s lien of a subcontractor may be posted is not required to pay the general contractor compensation for work done or material furnished for the building, land, or improvement until the expiration of ninety days after the completion of the building or improvement unless the general contractor furnishes to the owner one of the following: a. Receipts and waivers of claims for mechanics’ liens, signed by all persons who furnished material or performed labor for the building, land, or improvement.
    • statuteIowa Code § 572.33Aenactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      b. A good and sufficient bond to be approved by the owner, conditioned that the owner shall be held harmless from any loss which the owner may sustain by reason of the posting of mechanics’ liens by subcontractors. 2. This section applies only to commercial construction properties.
    • statuteIowa Code § 579B.6enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A waiver of a right created by this chapter, including but not limited to a waiver of the right to file a lien pursuant to this chapter, is void and unenforceable. This section does not affect other provisions of a contract, including a production contract or a related document, policy, or agreement which can be given effect without the voided provision.
    • statuteIowa Code § 572.2enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      An owner-builder is not entitled to a lien under this chapter as to work the owner-builder performs, or is contractually obligated to perform, prior to transferring title to the buyer.
    • statuteIowa Code § 572.1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      “Owner-builder” means the legal or equitable titleholder of record who furnishes material for or performs labor upon a building, erection, or other improvement, or who contracts with a subcontractor to furnish material for or perform labor upon a building, erection, or other improvement and who offers or intends to offer to sell the owner-builder’s property without occupying or using the structures, properties, developments, or improvements for a period of more than one year from the date the structure, property, development, or improvement is substantially completed or abandoned.
  9. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is the lien waiver our Kansas subcontract makes us sign enforceable?

    Only as far as you have been paid. In a contract for private construction, a provision that purports to waive, release or extinguish rights provided by article 11 of chapter 60 of the Kansas Statutes Annotated, the mechanic's lien article, is against public policy and is void and unenforceable, "except that a contract may require a contractor or subcontractor to provide a waiver or release of such rights as a condition for payment, but only to the extent of the amount of payment received" (K.S.A. 16-1803(b)(2)). The same subsection voids a provision purporting to waive, release or extinguish the right to resolve disputes through litigation in court or substantive or procedural rights in connection with that litigation, except that a contract may require binding arbitration as a substitute for litigation or non-binding alternative dispute resolution as a prerequisite to it. The words that trigger the act are defined: "construction" is furnishing labor, equipment, material or supplies used or consumed for the design, construction, alteration, renovation, repair or maintenance of a building, structure, road, bridge, water line, sewer line, oil line, gas line, appurtenance or other improvement to real property, including any moving, demolition or excavation, and a "contract" is one concerning construction between an owner and a contractor, a contractor and a subcontractor or a subcontractor and another subcontractor (K.S.A. 16-1802(b)-(c)). None of this can be contracted around: the rights and duties prescribed by the act are not waivable or varied under the terms of a contract, and the terms of any contract waiving them are unenforceable (K.S.A. 16-1801(b)).

    The trap

    The statute converts an up-front lien waiver into a receipt. A waiver demanded as a condition for payment is permitted, but only to the extent of the amount actually received, so a form that releases lien rights for work not yet paid for is outside the exception the statute allows. Watch the act's scope as well: it does not apply to single family residential housing or to multifamily residential housing of four units or less, does not apply to public works projects, and does not apply to contracts entered into before the act's effective date (K.S.A. 16-1807). Outside those boundaries this section gives a subcontractor nothing. Related and often missed: a pay-if-paid provision making payment to a subcontractor contingent on receipt of payment from another private party "is no defense to a claim to enforce a mechanic's lien or bond" under article 11 of chapter 60 (K.S.A. 16-1803(c)).

    as of 2026-10-08· reaches construction contracts only

    7 authorities

    • statuteK.S.A. 16-1803enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (2) a provision that purports to waive, release or extinguish rights provided by article 11 of chapter 60 of the Kansas Statutes Annotated, and amendments thereto, except that a contract may require a contractor or subcontractor to provide a waiver or release of such rights as a condition for payment, but only to the extent of the amount of payment received; and
    • statuteK.S.A. 16-1803enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (c) Any provision in a contract for private construction providing that a payment from a contractor or subcontractor to a subcontractor is contingent or conditioned upon receipt of a payment from any other private party, including a private owner, is no defense to a claim to enforce a mechanic's lien or bond to secure payment of claims pursuant to the provisions of article 11 of chapter 60 of the Kansas Statutes Annotated, and amendments thereto.
    • statuteK.S.A. 16-1801enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The rights and duties prescribed by this act shall not be waivable or varied under the terms of a contract. The terms of any contract waiving the rights and duties prescribed by this act shall be unenforceable.
    • statuteK.S.A. 16-1807enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The provisions of this act shall not apply to single family residential housing and multifamily residential housing of four units or less. The provisions of this act shall not apply to public works projects. The provisions of this act shall not apply to contracts entered into prior to the effective date of this act.
    • statuteK.S.A. 16-1803enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The following provisions in a contract for private construction shall be against public policy and shall be void and unenforceable: (1) A provision that purports to waive, release or extinguish the right to resolve disputes through litigation in court or substantive or procedural rights in connection with such litigation except that a contract may require binding arbitration as a substitute for litigation or require non-binding alternative dispute resolution as a prerequisite to litigation;
    • statuteK.S.A. 16-1803enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (3) a provision that purports to waive, release or extinguish rights of subrogation for losses or claims covered or paid by liability or workers compensation insurance except that a contract may require waiver of subrogation for losses or claims paid by a consolidated or wrap-up insurance program, owners and contractors protective liability insurance, or project management protective liability insurance, unless otherwise prohibited under subsection (b)(5) of K.S.A. 40-5403, and amendments thereto.
    • statuteK.S.A. 16-1802enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (b) "Construction" means furnishing labor, equipment, material or supplies used or consumed for the design, construction, alteration, renovation, repair or maintenance of a building, structure, road, bridge, water line, sewer line, oil line, gas line, appurtenance or other improvement to real property, including any moving, demolition or excavation. (c) "Contract" means a contract or agreement concerning construction made and entered into by and between an owner and a contractor, a contractor and a subcontractor or a subcontractor and another subcontractor.
  10. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is the up-front mechanics-lien waiver in our Maine subcontract enforceable?

    Nothing located in Maine law voids an advance lien waiver, and the whole mechanics-lien chapter was read section by section to say so: 10 M.R.S. §§ 3201 and 3251 to 3269, twenty sections, contain no anti-waiver provision and never use the word "waiver" at all. Maine's lien itself comes from § 3251, which gives a person who performs labour or furnishes labour or materials a lien "by virtue of a contract with or by consent of the owner ... on the land on which it stands and on any interest the owner has in the same, to secure payment thereof, with costs". What actually kills a Maine subcontractor's lien is not a waiver statute but three things in the chapter itself. First, deadlines: under § 3253 the lien "is dissolved unless the claimant, within 90 days after ceasing to labor, furnish materials or perform services" both records a sworn statement in the registry and mails a copy to the owner, and under § 3255(1) the lien must be enforced by an action filed "within 120 days after the last of the labor or services are performed". Second, a ceiling: where the claimant had no contract with the owner, § 3255(3) says the lien "may only be enforced against the property affected to the extent of the balance due to the person with whom the owner has directly contracted", so a subcontractor's lien is capped by what the owner still owes the general contractor, however large the subcontractor's own claim. Third, the owner's notice: under § 3252, where the work was not furnished under a contract with the owner, the owner "may prevent a lien under section 3251 for labor, materials or services not then performed or furnished, by giving written notice" that the owner will not be responsible. Waivers themselves are treated as ordinary commercial instruments and routinely enforced: in John W. Goodwin, Inc. v. Fox a subcontractor "provided lien waivers as it received payments" and signed one "indicating to Campbell and Fox that it had been paid in full for all work billed through that date", and in Jim's Plumbing & Heating, Inc. v. Home Loan Investment Bank the Law Court said a construction lender "could and should have required Bedford Falls to obtain lien waivers from all subcontractors prior to the disbursements".

    The trap

    Maine differs here from the states whose lien-waiver rules people carry across. Several states void or restrict a waiver given in advance of payment; Maine's lien chapter has no such provision anywhere in its twenty sections, so a Maine subcontractor who signs one is not protected by a statute that does not exist here. The out-of-state provisions are deliberately not cited, because the authority quoted below is Maine authority. Two things do protect the subcontractor, and neither is a waiver rule: the prompt-payment chapter's subcontractor payment and attorney-fee terms apply "[n]otwithstanding any contrary agreement" (10 M.R.S. §§ 1114(3), 1118(4)), and § 3252's notice route reaches only work "not then performed or furnished", so it cannot retroactively defeat a lien for work already done. The bigger trap is on the other side of the ledger, and it has nothing to do with waivers: § 3255(3)'s balance-due ceiling means a subcontractor who never contracted with the owner can win on the lien and still recover nothing if the owner has already paid the general contractor, and the defence is available only "with respect to sums paid by the owner to the person with whom the owner has directly contracted where payment was made prior to commencement of an action" or prior to the statutory written notice, so the notice is the step that stops the clock. The 90-day recording deadline in § 3253 does not apply "when the labor, materials or services are furnished by a contract with the owner of the property affected", which is why a general contractor and a subcontractor are on different timetables. Maine's prompt-payment chapter also preserves the payer's own leverage, which matters when a lien waiver is being demanded as the price of a payment that is itself being withheld: “Nothing in this chapter prevents an owner, contractor or subcontractor from withholding payment in whole or in part under a construction contract in an amount equalling the value of any good faith claims against an invoicing contractor, subcontractor or material supplier, including claims arising from unsatisfactory job progress, defective construction or materials, disputed work or 3rd-party claims.” The withholding has to be good faith and measured by the value of the claim, but within that the chapter takes nothing away.

    as of 2026-09-20· reaches construction contracts only

    12 authorities

    • statute10 M.R.S. § 3251enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      by virtue of a contract with or by consent of the owner, has a lien thereon and on the land on which it stands and on any interest the owner has in the same, to secure payment thereof, with costs.
    • statute10 M.R.S. § 3252enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If the labor, materials or services were not furnished by a contract with the owner of the property affected, the owner may prevent a lien under section 3251 for labor, materials or services not then performed or furnished, by giving written notice to the person performing or furnishing the labor, materials or services that the owner will not be responsible for the performing or furnishing of the labor, materials or services.
    • statute10 M.R.S. § 3253enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The lien under section 3252 is dissolved unless the claimant, within 90 days after ceasing to labor, furnish materials or perform services: A. Files in the office of the register of deeds in the county or registry district in which the building, wharf or pier is situated a true statement of the amount due the claimant, with all just credits given, together with a description of the property intended to be covered by the lien sufficiently accurate to identify it and the names of the owners, if known. The statement must be subscribed and sworn to by the person claiming the lien, or by someone in the claimant's behalf, and recorded in a book kept for that purpose by the register of deeds for the county or registry district, who is entitled to the same fees as for recording mortgages; and [PL 2005, c. 287, §1 (NEW).] B. Provides a copy of the statement under paragraph A to the owner or owners by ordinary mail. For purposes of this paragraph, a post office certificate of mailing the notice to the owner is conclusive proof of receipt by the owner.
    • statute10 M.R.S. § 3253enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This section does not apply when the labor, materials or services are furnished by a contract with the owner of the property affected.
    • statute10 M.R.S. § 3255enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The liens mentioned in sections 3251 to 3254 may be preserved and enforced by action against the debtor and owner of the property affected and all other parties interested therein, filed with the Superior Court or District Court clerk in the county or division where the house, building or appurtenances, wharf, pier or building thereon on which a lien is claimed is situated within 120 days after the last of the labor or services are performed or labor, materials or services are so furnished, except as provided in section 3256 .
    • statute10 M.R.S. § 3255enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If the labor, materials or services were not performed or furnished by a contract with the owner of the property affected, the lien described in this chapter may only be enforced against the property affected to the extent of the balance due to the person with whom the owner has directly contracted to perform or furnish the labor, materials and services on which that lien claim is based. The defense established by this subsection shall only be available with respect to sums paid by the owner to the person with whom the owner has directly contracted where payment was made prior to commencement of an action to enforce such lien by the person performing or furnishing labor, materials or services without a contract with the owner or a written notice from the person performing or furnishing labor, materials or services without a contract with the owner which sets forth a description of the property sufficiently accurate to identify
    • case2012 ME 124Jim's Plumbing & Heating, Inc. v. Home Loan Investment BankMe.decided 2012read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      In order to protect its mortgages’ *425 priorities, the Bank could and should have required Bedford Falls to obtain lien waivers from all subcontractors prior to the disbursements and should have tailored its disbursements to those waivers. The Bank failed to take these protective steps
    • case1999 ME 33John W. Goodwin, Inc. v. Foxme-medecided 1999read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Campbell paid Goodwin during the course of construction, and Goodwin provided lien waivers as it received payments. On December 12, 1990, Goodwin signed a lien waiver indicating to Campbell and Fox that it had been paid in full for all work billed through that date.
    • case1999 ME 33John W. Goodwin, Inc. v. Foxme-medecided 1999read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Consequently, the court did not commit clear error when it found that the retainage was the balance due Campbell from Fox and that Goodwin could enforce its lien against that sum. The entry is: Judgment affirmed.
    • statute10 M.R.S. § 1114enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Notwithstanding any contrary agreement, when a subcontractor or material supplier has performed in accordance with the provisions of a contract, a contractor shall pay to the subcontractor or material supplier, and each subcontractor shall in turn pay to its subcontractors or material suppliers, the full or proportional amount received for each subcontractor's work and materials based on work completed or service provided under the subcontract, 7 days after receipt of each progress or final payment or 7 days after receipt of the subcontractor's or material supplier's invoice, whichever is later.
    • statute10 M.R.S. § 1118enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Notwithstanding any contrary agreement, the substantially prevailing party in any proceeding to recover any payment within the scope of this chapter must be awarded reasonable attorney's fees in an amount to be determined by the court or arbitrator, together with expenses.
    • statute10 M.R.S. § 1118enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Nothing in this chapter prevents an owner, contractor or subcontractor from withholding payment in whole or in part under a construction contract in an amount equalling the value of any good faith claims against an invoicing contractor, subcontractor or material supplier, including claims arising from unsatisfactory job progress, defective construction or materials, disputed work or 3rd-party claims.
  11. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is the lien waiver our subcontract makes us sign up front enforceable in Minnesota?

    No, on the statute's own terms. Provisions contained in, or executed in connection with, a building and construction contract requiring a contractor, subcontractor or material supplier to waive the right to a mechanics lien or to a claim against a payment bond BEFORE the person has been paid for the labor or materials or both that the person furnished are void and unenforceable (Minn. Stat. § 337.10, subd. 2). The same subdivision preserves one exception on its face: 'This provision shall not affect the validity of a waiver as to any third party who detrimentally relies upon the waiver.'

    The trap

    The third-party-reliance sentence is the part that gets missed, and it can make a void waiver operative against you in practice: a lender or title company that detrimentally relies on the waiver you signed is protected by the statute even though the waiver is void as between you and the party who demanded it. Two scope points from the text itself. The subdivision reaches a 'building and construction contract' as defined in § 337.01 (a contract for the design, construction, alteration, improvement, repair or maintenance of real property, highways, roads or bridges), so it does not by its words reach a contract outside that definition, and the definition expressly excludes 'contracts for the maintenance or repair of machinery, equipment or other such devices used as part of a manufacturing, converting or other production process'. And the trigger is payment, not timing of signature: the waiver is void where it is required before the person 'has been paid for the labor or materials or both that the person furnished', so a waiver given for and limited to payment actually received is not what this subdivision voids. Minnesota's mechanics lien chapter itself (Minn. Stat. ch. 514) is not quoted in this rule, so nothing here states the content, form or timing requirements of a lien waiver or of a lien statement.

    as of 2026-09-17· reaches construction contracts only

    3 authorities

    • statuteMinn. Stat. § 337.10enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Provisions contained in, or executed in connection with, a building and construction contract requiring a contractor, subcontractor, or material supplier to waive the right to a mechanics lien or to a claim against a payment bond before the person has been paid for the labor or materials or both that the person furnished are void and unenforceable. This provision shall not affect the validity of a waiver as to any third party who detrimentally relies upon the waiver.
    • statuteMinn. Stat. § 337.01enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      "Building and construction contract" means a contract for the design, construction, alteration, improvement, repair or maintenance of real property, highways, roads or bridges. The term does not include contracts for the maintenance or repair of machinery, equipment or other such devices used as part of a manufacturing, converting or other production process, including electric, gas, steam, and telephone utility equipment used for production, transmission, or distribution purposes.
    • statuteMinn. Stat. § 337.10enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      For the purpose of this section, "building and construction contract" has the meaning given the term in section 337.01 .
  12. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Can we require a contractor, subcontractor, or material supplier to waive construction-lien or payment-bond rights before they are paid?

    No. § 28-2-723, MCA is a flat, unqualified void rule: “A construction contract may not contain provisions requiring a contractor, subcontractor, or material supplier to waive the right to a construction lien or a right to a claim against a payment bond before the contractor, subcontractor, or material supplier has been paid for the labor, materials, or both labor and materials, furnished.” The statute names the trigger for validity as PAYMENT, not contract signing or project completion: an advance waiver required as a condition of getting the job, before the work it covers is paid for, is exactly what the section prohibits. This sits alongside Montana's construction-lien chapter, which separately requires a lien claimant to give timely NOTICE of the right to claim a lien (generally within 20 days of first furnishing services or materials, or 45 days where a regulated lender is disbursing the project's funds), as a precondition to claiming the lien at all (§ 71-3-531). The notice is two steps, not one, and each carries its own bar. It must be “sent to the contracting owner by certified mail or delivered personally to the owner”, and “[a] person may not claim a construction lien unless the person has complied with this subsection” (§ 71-3-531(5)). A copy must also be filed with the clerk and recorder of the county where the property sits, in the form § 71-3-532 requires, “not ... later than 5 business days after the date on which the notice of the right to claim a lien is given to the contracting owner” (§ 71-3-531(6)(a)); the filed notice lapses after a year unless continued, and where notice is required at all “a person may not claim a construction lien pursuant to this part unless there is an unexpired notice of right to claim a construction lien or an unexpired continuation notice filed with the clerk and recorder at the time that the person files the lien” (§ 71-3-531(6)(e)).

    The trap

    § 28-2-723 was read in full and, unlike New Jersey's comparable lien-waiver statute, it names no partial exception for a waiver given specifically for work still to be provided, and no separate provision conditioning effectiveness on actual receipt of payment: Montana's rule is written as an outright bar on the REQUIREMENT to waive before payment, not a conditional-effectiveness rule. But that reading has not been tested in a Montana appellate opinion: the section is mentioned by no published Montana decision at any level, so no case confirms how a Montana court would treat a waiver signed before payment but expressed to take effect only once payment clears, or what remedy follows a violation (voidness of the waiver clause alone, unenforceability of the whole contract, or something else). Do not assume this section reaches every construction-adjacent waiver: it is worded around “construction contract” provisions specifically, and this rule did not independently verify its interaction with § 71-3-531's separate lien-rights NOTICE requirement, which has its own, unrelated exceptions (original contractors dealing directly with the owner, wage earners, and large or commercial projects are excused from giving that notice at all).

    as of 2026-09-20

    8 authorities

    • statuteMont. Code Ann. § 28-2-723enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A construction contract may not contain provisions requiring a contractor, subcontractor, or material supplier to waive the right to a construction lien or a right to a claim against a payment bond before the contractor, subcontractor, or material supplier has been paid for the labor, materials, or both labor and materials, furnished by the contractor, subcontractor, or material supplier.
    • statuteMont. Code Ann. § 71-3-531enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A person who may claim a construction lien pursuant to this part shall give notice of the right to claim a lien to the contracting owner in order to claim a lien.
    • statuteMont. Code Ann. § 71-3-531enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Except as provided in subsection (4), the notice may not be given later than 20 days after the date on which the services or materials are first furnished to the contracting owner. If notice is not given within this period, a lien is enforceable only for the services or materials furnished within the 20-day period before the date on which notice is given.
    • statuteMont. Code Ann. § 71-3-531enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      When payment for services or materials furnished pursuant to a real estate improvement contract, excluding a contract on an owner-occupied residence, is made by or on behalf of the contracting owner from funds provided by a regulated lender and secured by an interest, lien, mortgage, or encumbrance for the purpose of paying the particular real estate improvement being liened, the notice required by this section may not be given later than 45 days after the date on which the services or materials are first furnished to the contracting owner.
    • statuteMont. Code Ann. § 71-3-531enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The following are not required to give notice of the right to claim a lien as required by this section: (a) an original contractor who furnishes services or materials directly to the owner at the owner's request; (b) a wage earner or laborer who performs personal labor services for a person furnishing any service or material pursuant to a real estate improvement contract; (c) a person who furnishes services or materials pursuant to a real estate improvement contract that relates to a dwelling for five or more families; and (d) a person who furnishes services or materials pursuant to a real estate improvement contract that relates to an improvement that is partly or wholly commercial in character.
    • statuteMont. Code Ann. § 71-3-531enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The notice of the right to claim a lien must be sent to the contracting owner by certified mail or delivered personally to the owner. Notice by certified mail is effective on the date on which the notice is mailed. If the notice is delivered personally to the contracting owner, written acknowledgment of receipt must be obtained from the contracting owner. A person may not claim a construction lien unless the person has complied with this subsection.
    • statuteMont. Code Ann. § 71-3-531enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A person who may claim a lien shall also file with the clerk and recorder of the county in which the improved real estate is located a copy of the notice of the right to claim a lien, in the form required by 71-3-532 . This copy may not be filed later than 5 business days after the date on which the notice of the right to claim a lien is given to the contracting owner.
    • statuteMont. Code Ann. § 71-3-531enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If a notice of the right to claim a lien is required under this section, a person may not claim a construction lien pursuant to this part unless there is an unexpired notice of right to claim a construction lien or an unexpired continuation notice filed with the clerk and recorder at the time that the person files the lien.
  13. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is the up-front construction lien waiver in our subcontract enforceable in Nebraska?

    Yes. The statute says so in terms. Neb. Rev. Stat. § 52-144(1): “A written waiver of construction lien rights signed by a claimant requires no consideration and is valid and binding, whether signed before or after the materials or services were contracted for or furnished. Ambiguities in a written waiver are construed against the claimant.” Subsection (2) makes the default total rather than partial: “A written waiver waives all construction lien rights of the claimant as to the improvement to which the waiver relates unless the waiver is specifically limited to a particular lien right or a particular portion of the services or materials furnished.” Two things survive a waiver. § 52-144(3): “A waiver of lien rights does not affect any contract rights of the claimant otherwise existing.” And § 52-144(4): “Acceptance of a promissory note or other evidence of debt is not a waiver of lien rights unless the note or other instrument expressly so declares.” The Supreme Court has acknowledged the pre-attachment use in Nore Electric v. S & H Holdings, listing the owner's options: “The NCLA provides owners various options to avoid a construction lien from attaching to the real estate, such as procuring a surety bond”. The sentence continues, at the next footnote, with obtaining a written waiver of construction lien rights of a potential claimant. On public work there is nothing to waive: Neb. Rev. Stat. § 52-132 says “no lien attaches under sections 52-125 to 52-159 to real estate owned by the state, a county, a municipality, or other governmental agency or political subdivision”, and the right that matters there is the payment-bond claim, which Neb. Rev. Stat. § 45-1209(1) protects by voiding “[a] provision that purports to waive, release, or extinguish rights to file a claim against a payment or performance bond, except that a contract or subcontract may require a contractor or subcontractor to provide a waiver or release of such rights as a condition for payment, but only to the extent of the amount of the payment received”.

    The trap

    Nebraska inverts, in one sentence, the two protections a lien claimant relies on everywhere else. The advance waiver is good, “whether signed before or after”, so a no-lien covenant in the signature packet binds from day one; and it needs no consideration, so the usual “I was never paid for it” answer is gone. Ambiguity is construed AGAINST THE CLAIMANT, which is against the subcontractor or supplier and usually against the party who did not draft it, although the statutory test turns on being the claimant and not on who drafted the waiver: the opposite of the ordinary instinct, and the opposite of what the same body of Nebraska law does to an exculpatory clause, which Sinu v. Concordia University says is “strictly construed against the party claiming its benefit”. The practical consequence is subsection (2): a monthly progress-payment waiver that does not say in terms which lien right, which dates and which dollars it covers waives THE WHOLE JOB, and with ambiguity running against you there is no rescue. A RESEARCH TRAP SITS ON TOP OF THIS. Westland Homes Corp. v. Hall refused to enforce a lien release given for a check that bounced, holding “[i]n order to hold that the release was valid and effective in the absence of reliance, there would have to be some” showing of consideration, and it is dead law on that point, decided under the repealed mechanic's lien statutes before the Nebraska Construction Lien Act took effect on January 1, 1982. § 52-144(1) reverses its holding directly. A researcher who finds Westland and stops has the rule exactly backwards, and no later-treatment scan will catch it, because supersession by statute uses none of the words a scan looks for. From the owner's or general contractor's side the trap runs the other way: waivers from your subcontractor do nothing about that subcontractor's SUPPLIERS, who sign nothing and lien anyway. Echo Group v. Tradesmen International turned in part on exactly that, “Nor is there evidence that Lund-Ross asked for lien waivers from any of the suppliers”, and the supplier's three liens ($11,604.46, $32,781.03 and $296,407.73) survived every equitable defense on summary judgment.

    as of 2026-09-20· reaches construction contracts only

    19 authorities

    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 52-144enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A written waiver of construction lien rights signed by a claimant requires no consideration and is valid and binding, whether signed before or after the materials or services were contracted for or furnished. Ambiguities in a written waiver are construed against the claimant.
    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 52-144enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A written waiver waives all construction lien rights of the claimant as to the improvement to which the waiver relates unless the waiver is specifically limited to a particular lien right or a particular portion of the services or materials furnished.
    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 52-144enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A waiver of lien rights does not affect any contract rights of the claimant otherwise existing.
    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 52-144enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Acceptance of a promissory note or other evidence of debt is not a waiver of lien rights unless the note or other instrument expressly so declares.
    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 52-126enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Except as provided in sections 52-125 to 52-159 , no nonconsensual lien arises against real estate by reason of improvements made thereon.
    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 52-132enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Notwithstanding the provisions on existence of a construction lien of section 52-131 , no lien attaches under sections 52-125 to 52-159 to real estate owned by the state, a county, a municipality, or other governmental agency or political subdivision
    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 52-129enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Residential real estate shall mean, in relation to a protected party, real estate, improved or to be improved, containing not more than four dwelling units and no nonresidential uses for which the protected party is a lessor.
    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 52-135enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This section shall apply to a lien claimant only when the contracting owner is a protected party.
    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 52-143enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This section shall apply only when the real estate improvement contract is with a protected party.
    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 52-136enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Except as modified by subsections (4) and (5) of this section, as against a protected party contracting owner, the lien of a claimant other than a prime contractor is for the lesser of: (a) The amount unpaid under the claimant's contract; or (b) The amount unpaid under the prime contract through which the claimant claims at the time the contracting owner receives the claimant's notice of the right to assert a lien.
    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 45-1209enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The following provisions in any contract or subcontract for construction work performed within the State of Nebraska shall be against public policy and shall be void and unenforceable: (1) A provision that purports to waive, release, or extinguish rights to file a claim against a payment or performance bond, except that a contract or subcontract may require a contractor or subcontractor to provide a waiver or release of such rights as a condition for payment, but only to the extent of the amount of the payment received;
    • case316 Neb. 197Nore Electric v. S & H HoldingsNeb.decided 2024read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      The NCLA provides owners various options to avoid a construction lien from attaching to the real estate, such as procuring a surety bond 49 or obtaining a written waiver of construction lien rights of a potential claimant, 50 as well as methods for releasing the real estate from liens.
    • case980 N.W.2d 869Echo Group v. Tradesmen InternationalNeb.decided 2022read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Nor is there evidence that Lund-Ross asked for lien waivers from any of the suppliers.
    • case226 N.W.2d 622Westland Homes Corp. v. HallNeb.decided 1975read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      In order to hold that the release was valid and effective in the absence of reliance, there would have to be some showing’ of consideration. Under the facts here there was none.
    • case313 Neb. 218Sinu v. Concordia UniversityNeb.decided 2023read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      And such a clause is strictly construed against the party claiming its benefit.
    • case980 N.W.2d 869Echo Group v. Tradesmen InternationalNeb.decided 2022read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      In July 2019, Signature abruptly ceased operations. The next month, and in accordance with the Act, Echo recorded a construction lien in the office of the Douglas County register of deeds in each case in the amounts of $11,604.46, $32,781.03, and $296,407.73, respectively.
    • case980 N.W.2d 869Echo Group v. Tradesmen InternationalNeb.decided 2022read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      In all three appeals, we find no abuse of discretion by the court in entering summary judgment and not granting equitable relief.
    • case226 N.W.2d 622Westland Homes Corp. v. HallNeb.decided 1975read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Westland was entitled to a subcontractor’s lien under the specific provisions of section 52-102, R. R. S. 1943.
    • statuteNeb. Rev. Stat. § 45-1210enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Any liquidated or unliquidated claim against any political subdivision of this state arising from construction performed for such political subdivision shall: (a) Be presented in writing to the individual or officer as set forth in subsection (2) of this section; (b) state the name of the claimant and the amount of the claim; and (c) identify the item or service for which payment is claimed or the time, place, nature, and circumstance giving rise to the claim. All claims shall be filed within one hundred eighty days after the date of substantial completion of the construction project.
  14. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is the up-front lien waiver in our subcontract enforceable in New Jersey?

    Only to the extent of payment actually received. A waiver of construction lien rights is against public policy, unlawful and void unless given in consideration for payment for the work, services, materials or equipment provided or to be provided, and even then it is effective only upon and to the extent that the payment is actually received (N.J.S.A. 2A:44A-38).

    The trap

    This defeats both halves of the standard contractor playbook in one sentence. A no-lien covenant given for nothing but the award of the subcontract is void; a waiver given in consideration for payment, including payment for work still to be provided, is not void, but it is worthless until paid: effective only 'upon and to the extent that such payment is actually received', so, on the section's words, a waiver is effective only to the extent of payment actually received.

    as of 2026-09-17· reaches construction contracts only

    4 authorities

    • statuteN.J. Stat. Ann. § 2A:44A-38enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Waivers of construction lien rights are against public policy, unlawful, and void, unless given in consideration for payment for the work, services, materials or equipment provided or to be provided, and such waivers shall be effective only upon and to the extent that such payment is actually received.
    • case163 N.J. 507Thomas Group, Inc. v. Wharton Senior Citizen Housing, Inc.N.J.decided 2000read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      In addition, as a benefit to contractors, the Construction Lien Law codified a prohibition on waivers. Waivers had been permitted under the Mechanic’s Lien Law, and contractors often were pressured to waive their Ken rights in exchange for signing construction contracts. Under the new Construction Lien Law, waivers on construction Ken rights are deemed void and against public policy “unless given in consideration for payment for the work, services, materials, or equipment provided, and ... [are] effective only upon and to the extent that such payment is actually received.” N.J.S.A. 2A:44A-38.
    • case163 N.J. 507Thomas Group, Inc. v. Wharton Senior Citizen Housing, Inc.N.J.decided 2000read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      The Legislature’s primary purpose in revising the Lien Law was to simplify the lien-filing process. That was accomplished by streamlining the process to eliminate the prior law’s pre-filing requirement, which had caused tension between contractors and owners, and by abolishing lien waivers, which impinged on con *517 tractors’ rights to obtain construction liens.
    • case(N.J. Mar. 23, 2004)Craft v. Stevenson Lumber Yard, Inc.N.J.decided 2004
      Show the words that state the rule
      An owner also may require a contractor to obtain lien waivers from subcontractors *71 and suppliers as they are paid, N.J.S.A. 2A:44A-38, but under the CLL such waivers are not considered essential because the property is protected to the extent that payments the owner has made are subtracted from the total contract price in measuring the lien fund.
  15. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Can we get the subcontractor to give up its mechanic's lien rights in the subcontract?

    No. Lien Law § 34 provides that notwithstanding any other law, any contract, agreement or understanding whereby the right to file or enforce a lien created under article 2 is waived is void as against public policy and wholly unenforceable. The section does not preclude a requirement for a written waiver of the right to FILE a mechanic's lien executed and delivered simultaneously with or after payment for the labour or materials covered (the saving words reach only the right to file, while the voiding sentence reaches the right 'to file or enforce'), nor is the section applicable to a written agreement to subordinate, release or satisfy all or part of such a lien made after a notice of lien has been filed. The prohibition reaches functional waivers as well as express ones: a pay-when-paid provision that forces the subcontractor to assume the risk that the owner will fail to pay the general contractor is void and unenforceable as contrary to the public policy set forth in Lien Law § 34, while a provision that merely fixes a TIME for payment is valid (West-Fair, answering in the affirmative the first of two questions certified to the Court of Appeals by the Second Circuit and leaving the second, on the surety's liability under the payment bond, 'not answered as academic'; there the owner had become insolvent, so further payment was 'virtually certain' not to come and the subcontractor's right to payment was 'indefinitely postponed'). Article 35-E lists five void provisions, two of which a payment clause hits directly: a provision stating that a party "cannot suspend performance under the contract if another party to the contract fails to make prompt payments" is void (GBL § 757(2)), as is one requiring retainage "in an amount exceeding five percent of the contract sum" (§ 757(5)), and the article reaches only construction contracts where the aggregate cost of the project is at least $150,000, excluding public-works projects and their subcontracts, individual one-, two- and three-family dwellings, a residential tract development of a hundred or fewer one- or two-family dwellings, residential projects of 4,500 square feet or less, and certain subsidised residential projects of fewer than seventy-five units (§ 756(1)).

    The trap

    Two New York traps sit on top of each other. First, the timing rule: a lien waiver signed up front is void, but a written waiver of the right to file, executed and delivered simultaneously with or after the payment it covers, falls outside the section, so the enforceability of a subcontractor's waiver turns on the date next to the signature, and on whether what was given up was the right to file or the right to enforce. Second, the condition-precedent trap: New York construes a payment-on-a-stipulated-event clause as a time-for-payment clause UNLESS there is express language to the contrary, so the drafter who writes what the West-Fair subcontract wrote (that 'THE PAYMENT TO THE TRADE CONTRACTOR [plaintiff] IS DEPENDENT, AS A CONDITION PRECEDENT, UPON THE construction manager [the general contractor] RECEIVING CONTRACT PAYMENTS, INCLUDING RETAINER FROM THE OWNER') converts a valid timing clause into a void risk-shifting one; the Court held that 'the unambiguous language of section 3.2 places the risk of the owner's inability or failure to pay the general contractor squarely upon plaintiff', so that the subcontractor 'has effectively waived its right to enforce its mechanics' liens'. Note the escape used in Welsbach, and how little it gives you. It was not the same clause: Welsbach's was a pay-IF-paid condition precedent ('all payments to Subcontractor by Contractor are expressly contingent upon and subject to receipt of payment for the Work by Contractor from Owner'), and Welsbach warns in a footnote that the 'when' and 'if' formulations 'are different', Schuler-Haas's when-clause having been read as 'not... a condition precedent but a timing mechanism'. Nor was the clause enforced: both sides agreed it violated New York public policy, and but for the choice-of-law point the Court 'would simply apply Lien Law § 34 as interpreted in West-Fair and the case would be closed'. What saved it was the parties' Florida choice of law with neither party a New York corporation, and all the Court did was reverse the striking of the general contractor's affirmative defences and answer a certified question in the negative. For a covered contract made today the route is shut: Welsbach records in a footnote that 'it was not until 2002 that New York enacted section 757 of the General Business Law rendering void any provision that makes a construction contract subject to the laws of another state', and § 757(1) voids out-of-state choice-of-law and forum clauses in a construction contract 'with the exception of a contract with a material supplier'.

    as of 2026-09-16· reaches construction contracts only

    19 authorities

    • statuteN.Y. LIE Law § 34enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Notwithstanding the provisions of any other law, any contract, agreement or understanding whereby the right to file or enforce any lien created under article two is waived, shall be void as against public policy and wholly unenforceable.
    • statuteN.Y. LIE Law § 34enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This section shall not preclude a requirement for a written waiver of the right to file a mechanic's lien executed and delivered by a contractor, subcontractor, material supplier or laborer simultaneously with or after payment for the labor performed or the materials furnished has been made to such contractor, subcontractor, material man or laborer nor shall this section be applicable to a written agreement to subordinate, release or satisfy all or part of such a lien made after a notice of lien has been filed.
    • case87 N.Y.2d 148West-Fair Electric Contractors v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.N.Y.decided 1995read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      We hold that a pay-when-paid provision which forces the subcontractor to assume the risk that the owner will fail to pay the general contractor is void and unenforceable as contrary to public policy set forth in the Lien Law § 34. By contrast, a pay-when-paid provision which merely fixes a time for payment does not indefinitely suspend a subcontractor’s right to payment upon the failure of an owner to pay the general contractor, and does not violate public policy as stated in the Lien Law.
    • case87 N.Y.2d 148West-Fair Electric Contractors v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.N.Y.decided 1995read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Following certification of questions by the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit and acceptance of the *160 questions by this Court pursuant to section 500.17 of the Rules of the Court of Appeals (22 NYCRR 500.17), and after hearing argument by counsel for the parties and consideration of the briefs and the record submitted, certified question No. 1 answered in the affirmative, and certified question No. 2 not answered as academic.
    • statuteN.Y. GBS Law § 757enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      § 757. Void provisions. The following provisions of construction contracts shall be void and unenforceable: 1. A provision, covenant, clause or understanding in, collateral to or affecting a construction contract, with the exception of a contract with a material supplier, that makes the contract subject to the laws of another state or that requires any litigation, arbitration or other dispute resolution proceeding arising from the contract to be conducted in another state.
    • case87 N.Y.2d 148West-Fair Electric Contractors v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.decided 1995read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      We reject plaintiff’s argument that the pay-when-paid provision in section 3.2 of the subcontract merely fixed a time for payment. A contract provision stating that payment will occur upon a stipulated event will be construed as a time for payment provision unless there is express language to the contrary in the contract
    • statuteN.Y. GBS Law § 757enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      2. A provision, covenant, clause or understanding in, collateral to or affecting a construction contract stating that a party to the contract cannot suspend performance under the contract if another party to the contract fails to make prompt payments under the contract.
    • statuteN.Y. GBS Law § 757enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      5. A provision, covenant, clause or understanding in, collateral to or affecting a construction contract requiring retainage as expressly provided for by section seven hundred fifty-six-c of this article in an amount exceeding five percent of the contract sum.
    • statuteN.Y. GBS Law § 756enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      1. "Construction contract" means a written or oral agreement for the construction, reconstruction, alteration, maintenance, moving or demolition of any building, structure or improvement, or relating to the excavation of or other development or improvement to land, and where the aggregate cost of the construction project including all labor, services, materials and equipment to be furnished, equals or exceeds one hundred fifty thousand dollars. For the purposes of this article a construction contract shall not include any such contract made and awarded by the state, any public department, any public benefit corporation, any public corporation or official thereof, or a municipal corporation or official thereof for construction, reconstruction, alteration, repair, maintenance, moving or demolition of any public works project nor any contract with a contractor or subcontractor which is part of such project; or any such contract the purpose of which is the construction, reconstruction, alteration, repair, maintenance, moving or demolition of an individual one, two or three family residential dwelling or a residential tract development of one hundred or less one or two family dwellings, or any residential construction project where the aggregate size of such project is four thousand five hundred square feet or less, or any residential project of fewer than seventy-five units which receives financial assistance from the federal government, the state or a municipal entity designed for households earning an average of one hundred twenty-five percent of the housing and urban development agency area median income.
    • case87 N.Y.2d 148West-Fair Electric Contractors v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.N.Y.decided 1995read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Section 3.2 of the subcontract agreement provides in relevant part: "it is specifically understood and agreed that THE PAYMENT TO THE TRADE CONTRACTOR [plaintiff] IS DEPENDENT, AS A CONDITION PRECEDENT, UPON THE construction manager [the general contractor] RECEIVING CONTRACT PAYMENTS, INCLUDING RETAINER FROM THE OWNER”.
    • case87 N.Y.2d 148West-Fair Electric Contractors v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.N.Y.decided 1995read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      In contrast, the face of the subcontract here explicitly makes payment from the owner to the general contractor a "condition precedent” to any payment to plaintiff. Since the unambiguous language of section 3.2 places the risk of the owner’s inability or failure to pay the general contractor squarely upon plaintiff, the pay-when-paid provision here cannot be construed as a time for payment clause.
    • case87 N.Y.2d 148West-Fair Electric Contractors v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.N.Y.decided 1995read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      However, a pay-when-paid provision as a condition precedent requires plaintiff to defer payment for its work until the general contractor has been paid by the owner. As the owner here has become insolvent, the owner may never make another contract payment to the general contractor. Because the lack of future payments by the owner is virtually certain, plaintiff’s right to receive payment has been indefinitely postponed, and plaintiff has effectively waived its right to enforce its mechanics’ liens.
    • case7 N.Y.3d 624Welsbach Electric Corp. v. MasTec North America, Inc.N.Y.decided 2006read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      In the case before us, plaintiff subcontractor is a Delaware corporation and defendant general contractor is a Florida corporation. The parties agreed that Florida law would govern their contract. Unlike New York, Florida allows pay-if-paid contracts. We must determine whether New York’s public policy against such contracts is so fundamental that it should override the parties’ choice of law. We hold that it is not, and that the parties’ choice of law controls.
    • case7 N.Y.3d 624Welsbach Electric Corp. v. MasTec North America, Inc.N.Y.decided 2006read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      The subcontract included a pay-if-paid clause stating that: “Upon final acceptance of the Work by Contractor and Owner, Contractor will pay Subcontractor for the Work at the prices and schedule and in the manner described in Schedule 1; provided that, all payments to Subcontractor by Contractor are expressly contingent upon and subject to receipt of payment for *628 the Work by Contractor from Owner
    • case7 N.Y.3d 624Welsbach Electric Corp. v. MasTec North America, Inc.N.Y.decided 2006read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Both sides agree that the subcontract’s pay-if-paid clause violates New York’s public policy. 2 Were we not dealing with choice of law, we would simply apply Lien Law § 34 as inter *629 preted in West-Fair and the case would be closed.
    • case7 N.Y.3d 624Welsbach Electric Corp. v. MasTec North America, Inc.decided 2006read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Section 34 seeks to protect New York subcontractors from the oppressive use of bargaining power. Here, neither party is a New York corporation; notably, MasTec is a Florida corporation. As dissenting Justice Krausman pointed out, both are sophisticated commercial entities that knowingly and voluntarily entered into the subcontract.
    • case7 N.Y.3d 624Welsbach Electric Corp. v. MasTec North America, Inc.N.Y.decided 2006read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Accordingly, the order of the Appellate Division should be reversed, with costs, plaintiffs motion, insofar as it seeks to dismiss the fifth and eleventh affirmative defenses interposed in the answer, denied and the certified question answered in the negative.
    • case7 N.Y.3d 624Welsbach Electric Corp. v. MasTec North America, Inc.N.Y.decided 2006read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      We found this not to be a condition precedent but a timing mechanism ( 40 NY2d 883, *629 885 [1976]). We need not discuss the different ramifications of the “when” versus “if” formulations, which have been the subject of extensive commentary
    • case7 N.Y.3d 624Welsbach Electric Corp. v. MasTec North America, Inc.N.Y.decided 2006read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Moreover, it was not until 2002 that New York enacted section 757 of the General Business Law rendering void any provision that makes a construction contract subject to the laws of another state.
  16. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is the lien waiver our subcontract makes us sign to get a progress payment enforceable?

    Only if it is limited to the interim or progress payment actually received. N.C.G.S. § 22B-5(a) makes provisions in lien waivers, releases, construction agreements as defined in G.S. 22B-1(f)(1), or design professional agreements as defined in G.S. 22B-1(f)(5) that purport to require a promisor to submit a waiver or release of liens or claims as a condition of receiving interim or progress payments due from a promisee 'void and unenforceable unless limited to the specific interim or progress payment actually received by the promisor in exchange for the lien waiver'. The operative words are 'actually received': the test is not whether the waiver is conditional in form but whether it is confined to the payment the promisor in fact got. Be careful about what the statute then does, because this is the point most often assumed. Its words make the offending provision 'void and unenforceable' and stop there. They do not say that an over-broad waiver is cut back to the payment received, and whether a North Carolina court would enforce such a waiver up to that amount rather than strike it was not established here: no North Carolina decision was examined for this answer. Both agreement types § 22B-5 operates on are defined in G.S. 22B-1(f), and 'design professional agreement' is defined through 'design professional', which G.S. 22B-1(f)(4) confines to a person or entity licensed under and providing professional services regulated by Chapters 83A, 89A, 89C, 89E or 89F of the General Statutes.

    The trap

    Read subsection (b) before relying on the section. It takes two situations out of § 22B-5 entirely: lien waivers or releases for FINAL payments, and agreements to settle and compromise disputed claims after the claim has been identified by the claimant in writing, regardless of whether the promisor has started a civil action or an arbitration. So the broad release attached to the final application for payment is outside the protection, as is the release in a settlement of a claim the subcontractor has already put in writing. The section is also bounded by the definitions it borrows: 'construction agreement' in G.S. 22B-1(f)(1) is a contract relative to the design, planning, construction, alteration, repair or maintenance of a building, structure, highway, road, appurtenance or appliance, including moving, demolition and excavating connected with it, and 'design professional agreement' in G.S. 22B-1(f)(5) reaches only an agreement with a design professional, which G.S. 22B-1(f)(4) ties to licensure under Chapters 83A, 89A, 89C, 89E or 89F. NOT ESTABLISHED HERE: whether a lien waiver that recites payment the subcontractor never received is effective against an owner who relied on it, and the mechanics of the lien itself under Chapter 44A. No Chapter 44A section and no North Carolina opinion was read for this rule. Two measurements show how wide that reservation is. A search of North Carolina case law finds a single Court of Appeals decision that mentions § 22B-5; it was not read here, and whether it is citable authority was not determined. And a re-run of the search across the published North Carolina statutes finds 'waiver of lien' and 'waiver of liens' in § 22B-5 alone, but 'release of lien' in seven sections and 'release of liens' in four (among them §§ 44A-24.11, 47C-4-111, 93A-57 and 93A-58), and 'lien rights' in §§ 143-128.1C, 44A-11.2 and 44-50.1. None of those sections was read for this answer, so what any of them does to a progress-payment release is open. Where this rule reaches for § 22B-1, that section stops short of two things: “This section shall not affect an insurance contract, workers' compensation, or any other agreement issued by an insurer. This section shall not apply to lien or bond claims asserted under Chapter 44A of the General Statutes.” The second matters most here, because a progress-payment lien waiver fight is a Chapter 44A fight, and § 22B-1 does not reach it. But read that carve-out to the right section: it is § 22B-1 that excludes Chapter 44A claims, not § 22B-5, whose only exclusions are the two in its own subsection (b). The Chapter 44A character of a lien fight is therefore not by itself a reason § 22B-5 would fail to reach the waiver.

    as of 2026-09-17· reaches construction contracts only

    5 authorities

    • statuteN.C.G.S. § 22B-5enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Provisions in lien waivers, releases, construction agreements as defined in G.S. 22B-1(f)(1), or design professional agreements as defined in G.S. 22B-1(f)(5) purporting to require a promisor to submit a waiver or release of liens or claims as a condition of receiving interim or progress payments due from a promisee under a construction agreement or design professional agreement are void and unenforceable unless limited to the specific interim or progress payment actually received by the promisor in exchange for the lien waiver.
    • statuteN.C.G.S. § 22B-5enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This section does not apply to the following: (1) Lien waivers or releases for final payments. (2) Agreements to settle and compromise disputed claims after the claim has been identified by the claimant in writing regardless of whether the promisor has initiated a civil action or arbitration proceeding.
    • statuteN.C.G.S. § 22B-1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (f) For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply: (1) Construction agreement. - Any promise or agreement in, or in connection with, a contract or agreement relative to the design, planning, construction, alteration, repair, or maintenance of a building, structure, highway, road, appurtenance, or appliance, including moving, demolition, and excavating connected therewith.
    • statuteN.C.G.S. § 22B-1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This section shall not affect an insurance contract, workers' compensation, or any other agreement issued by an insurer. This section shall not apply to lien or bond claims asserted under Chapter 44A of the General Statutes.
    • statuteN.C.G.S. § 22B-1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (4) Design professional. - A person or entity who is licensed under and provides professional services regulated by Chapters 83A, 89A, 89C, 89E, or 89F of the General Statutes. (5) Design professional agreement. - Any promise or agreement in, or in connection with, a contract or agreement with a design professional to provide design professional services. (6) Design professional services. - A service or work performed by a design professional for which licensure is required under Chapters 83A, 89A, 89C, 89E, or 89F of the General Statutes.
  17. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is a construction lien waiver signed by our subcontractor enforceable in North Dakota, even one signed before payment?

    Yes, on the statute's own words, regardless of when it is signed or whether payment has actually been made. N.D.C.C. § 35-27-02(3): "If the owner, trustee, or agent of the owner has received a valid waiver of lien, signed by the person that improves the real estate, a lien is not allowed." Spier v. Power Concrete, Inc. dates that proviso rather than applying it. A footnote there sets out the section as it stood before 1 July 1979, with no waiver proviso in it at all, and then recites that "Section 35-27-02, NDCC, was amended in 1979 and the amended law, which became effective on 1 July 1979, reads as follows:" followed by the proviso in words the section still carries: "Provided further that if the owner or an agent of the owner has received a waiver of lien signed by the person who improves the real estate by the contribution of labor, skill, or materials, no lien shall be allowed." Spier itself decided a notice question on the rule that "[r]ights under a mechanic's lien are governed by the law in force at the time the right accrued." The decision that applies the proviso is Peterson Mechanical, Inc. v. Nereson: "A party entitled to a mechanic's lien may waive that right by a signed writing [NDCC 35-27-02; see NDCC 1-01-08; 1-02-28], or may be estopped to assert the mechanic's lien by acts or conduct constituting estoppel."

    The trap

    Unlike New Jersey's construction-lien-waiver statute, N.J.S.A. 2A:44A-38, which makes a waiver void unless given in consideration for payment and effective only to the extent payment is actually received, nothing in N.D.C.C. § 35-27-02's text conditions a waiver's effectiveness on consideration, on payment, or on timing; a signed waiver defeats the lien on its face whether it was signed before or after the work was done or paid for. Two things do qualify the statute's silence, and neither of them is consideration. The waiver has to be real: Peterson Mechanical states that "[a] waiver requires voluntary and intentional relinquishment of a known right or privilege," so a signature obtained from someone who did not know of the right is open to attack on that ground rather than for want of payment, and the same decision treats estoppel as a separate route to the same result. And N.D.C.C. § 1-02-28, which Peterson Mechanical cites for the power to waive at all, allows the benefit of a statute to "be waived by any party entitled thereto, unless such waiver would be against public policy." Whether a court would use that proviso to read a payment condition into § 35-27-02 is still unanswered. Two further limits in the same section have nothing to do with waiver: anyone extending credit to the owner's contractor must give the owner written notice "by certified mail at least ten days before the recording of the construction lien," and "[n]otwithstanding any provision in this section, any person that performs labor or furnishes materials or services under chapter 35-24 is prohibited from claiming or maintaining a lien under this chapter."

    as of 2026-09-21

    10 authorities

    • statuteN.D.C.C. § 35-27-02enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If the owner, trustee, or agent of the owner has received a valid waiver of lien, signed by the person that improves the real estate, a lien is not allowed.
    • statuteN.D.C.C. § 35-27-02enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Any person that improves real estate under a contract with the owner of the real estate or under contract with any agent, trustee, contractor, or subcontractor of the owner, has a lien upon the improvement and upon the land on which the improvement is situated or to which the improvement may be removed for the price or value of the contribution. - The amount of the lien is limited to the difference between the price paid by the owner, trustee, or agent and the price or value of the contribution. If the owner, trustee, or agent has paid the full price or value of the contribution, no lien is allowed.
    • case304 N.W.2d 68Spier v. Power Concrete, Inc.N.D.decided 1981read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Provided further that if the owner or an agent of the owner has received a waiver of lien signed by the person who improves the real estate by the contribution of labor, skill, or materials, no lien shall be allowed.
    • case304 N.W.2d 68Spier v. Power Concrete, Inc.N.D.decided 1981read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Section 35-27-02, NDCC, was amended in 1979 and the amended law, which became effective on 1 July 1979, reads as follows:
    • statuteN.D.C.C. § 35-27-02enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Any person that extends credit or makes a contract with any agent, trustee, contractor, or subcontractor of the owner for the improvement of real estate, upon demand, has the right to request and secure evidence of the legal description of the real estate upon which the improvement is located, including the name of the legal or equitable owner of the real estate. Written notice a lien will be claimed must be given to the legal or equitable owner of the real estate by certified mail at least ten days before the recording of the construction lien. - Notwithstanding any provision in this section, any person that performs labor or furnishes materials or services under chapter 35-24 is prohibited from claiming or maintaining a lien under this chapter.
    • statuteN.D.C.C. § 1-02-28enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Except when it is declared otherwise, the provisions of this code in respect to the rights and obligations of parties to contracts are subordinate to the intention of the parties, when ascertained in the manner prescribed by the chapter on the interpretation of contracts. The benefit thereof may be waived by any party entitled thereto, unless such waiver would be against public policy.
    • case466 N.W.2d 568Peterson Mechanical, Inc. v. NeresonN.D.decided 1991read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      A party entitled to a mechanic’s lien may waive that right by a signed writing [NDCC 35-27-02; see NDCC 1-01-08; 1-02-28], or may be estopped to assert the mechanic’s lien by acts or conduct constituting estoppel.
    • case466 N.W.2d 568Peterson Mechanical, Inc. v. NeresonN.D.decided 1991read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      A waiver requires voluntary and intentional relinquishment of a known right or privilege. Peterson v. Front Page, Inc., 462 N.W.2d 157 (N.D.1990).
    • case304 N.W.2d 68Spier v. Power Concrete, Inc.N.D.decided 1981read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      A mechanic’s lien is purely a creature of statute, and the statutory requirements must be fairly met. Schaffer v. Smith, 113 N.W.2d 688 (N.D.1962). Rights under a mechanic’s lien are governed by the law in force at the time the right accrued.
    • case304 N.W.2d 68Spier v. Power Concrete, Inc.N.D.decided 1981read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      At the time of Spiers’ contract with Dakota Building, § 35-27-02, NDCC, provided as follows: “Any person who improves real estate by the contribution of labor, skill, or materials under contract with the owner of such real estate shall have a lien upon the improvement, and upon the land on which it is situated or to which it may be removed, for the price or value of such contribution. Provided, however, that the amount of the lien shall only be for the difference between the price paid by the owner and the price or value of the contribution. If the owner has paid the full price or value of the contribution, no lien shall be allowed. No person shall have a lien for improving real estate resulting from extending credit to or making a contract with any agent, trustee, contractor, or subcontractor of such owner unless such person first notifies the owner in writing of the provisions of chapter 35-27
  18. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Does the lien waiver in this subcontract, or the lack of one, decide whether the subcontractor can lien the job?

    On the Ohio authority verified here, what decides a subcontractor's lien is the notice of furnishing, not the waiver. R.C. 1311.05(A), as the Eighth District set it out, requires a subcontractor or material supplier who performs labour or work upon or furnishes material in furtherance of an improvement to real property and who wishes to preserve its lien rights to serve a notice of furnishing on the owner's, part owner's or lessee's designee named in the notice of commencement and on the original contractor within twenty-one days after performing the first labour or work or furnishing the first materials (Pitt). That requirement turns on status: original contractors and construction managers contract with the owner directly, and R.C. 1311.01 defines subcontractor, original contractor and construction manager, as Panzica quotes it. Two timing provisions in the same section cut the other way. Where the owner records a notice of commencement but does so after the first labour, work or material, subcontractors and material suppliers have twenty-one days after that notice to file a notice of furnishing and need not serve one for the earlier period (R.C. 1311.04(I)); and where the owner fails to record a notice of commencement at all, or records one that is materially deficient, a subcontractor is not required to serve a notice of furnishing to preserve its lien rights (R.C. 1311.04(R)).

    The trap

    No Ohio provision voiding an advance lien waiver was located for this rule: R.C. Chapter 1311 is outside our published statutes and no opinion read here quoted such a subsection, so a subcontractor who signs one in Ohio cannot rely on this rule to escape it, and an owner should not read this rule as blessing one either. The live Ohio risk in the cases read is the twenty-one-day clock: in Pitt the general contractor argued that the subcontractor's not filing a lien showed no reliance because the lien would have been untimely under R.C. 1311.05 anyway, and the Ninth District disagreed, holding every element of promissory estoppel established and affirming judgment for the subcontractor. Whether the twenty-one-day rule applies at all depends on whether the claimant is a subcontractor or an original contractor or construction manager as R.C. 1311.01 defines those terms, and Panzica turned on exactly that classification. On a home construction contract a different bar can end the claim whatever the notice says: under R.C. 1311.011(B)(1) a subcontractor may not obtain a lien for work on such a contract where the homeowner paid the original contractor in full before receiving a copy of the subcontractor's lien (Almasoodi).

    as of 2026-09-17· reaches construction contracts only

    8 authorities

    • case2024-Ohio-2297Pitt v. Quanta Bldg. GroupOhio Ct. App. 9th Dist.decided 2024
      Show the words that state the rule
      RC. 1311.05(A) states that a lien must be filed within 21 days after performing the first work or furnishing the first materials, unless that time is extended. {¶14} The statute allows for a twenty-one day window to file a notice of furnishing after the commencement of work.
    • case2015-Ohio-3478Panzica Constr. Co. v. Bridgeview Crossing, L.L.C.Ohio Ct. App. 8th Dist.decided 2015
      Show the words that state the rule
      In the event that an owner does record a notice of commencement but does so after the first work, labor, or material has been performed on, or furnished to, the improvement, then subcontractors and material suppliers have 21 days after the notice of commencement to file a notice of furnishing in order to perfect their liens, and they need not serve a notice of furnishing to preserve lien rights for the period before the notice of commencement is recorded. R.C. 1311.04(I).
    • case2024-Ohio-2297Pitt v. Quanta Bldg. GroupOhio Ct. App. 9th Dist.decided 2024
      Show the words that state the rule
      Jones Corp. argues that Mr. Pitt’s failure to file a mechanic’s lien did not establish reliance because, pursuant to R.C. 1311.05, Mr. Pitt’s lien would have been untimely.
    • case2024-Ohio-2297Pitt v. Quanta Bldg. GroupOhio Ct. App. 9th Dist.decided 2024
      Show the words that state the rule
      the trial court did not err by entering judgment in Mr. Pitt’s favor on the claim of promissory estoppel because the record demonstrates that Mr. Pitt established all of the elements of a claim for promissory estoppel. Accordingly, Jones Corp.’s first assignment of error is overruled.
    • case2024-Ohio-2297Pitt v. Quanta Bldg. GroupOhio Ct. App. 9th Dist.decided 2024
      Show the words that state the rule
      “[A] subcontractor * * * who performs labor or work upon or furnishes material in furtherance of an improvement to real property and who wishes to preserve the subcontractor’s or material supplier’s lien rights shall serve a notice of furnishing * * * upon the owner’s, part owner’s, or lessee’s designee named in the notice of commencement or amended notice and the original contractor under the original contract pursuant to which the subcontractor or material supplier is performing labor or work or furnishing materials * * * within twenty-one days after performing the first labor or work or furnishing the first materials.”)
    • case2015-Ohio-3478Panzica Constr. Co. v. Bridgeview Crossing, L.L.C.Ohio Ct. App. 8th Dist.decided 2015
      Show the words that state the rule
      If an owner does not record a notice of commencement prior to the start of work, then the original contractor may request, in writing, that the owner record a notice of commencement and serve it on all of the various contractors and subcontractors. R.C. 1311.04(M)(1). If the owner fails to record a notice of commencement, or if a notice of commencement is recorded but is materially deficient in some way, then a subcontractor is not required to issue a notice of furnishing to preserve its lien rights. R.C. 1311.04(R).
    • case2015-Ohio-3478Panzica Constr. Co. v. Bridgeview Crossing, L.L.C.Ohio Ct. App. 8th Dist.decided 2015
      Show the words that state the rule
      R.C. 1311.01 provides the following definitions: (D) “Subcontractor” includes any person who undertakes to construct, alter, erect, improve, repair, demolish, remove, dig, or drill any part of any improvement under a contract with any person other than the owner, part owner, or lessee. (E) “Original contractor,” except as otherwise provided in section 1311.011 of the Revised Code, includes a construction manager and any person who undertakes to construct, alter, erect, improve, repair, demolish, remove, dig, or drill any part of any improvement under a contract with an owner, part owner, or lessee.
    • case2023-Ohio-895Almasoodi v. J. Harris Constr. Inc.Ohio Ct. App. 5th Dist.decided 2023
      Show the words that state the rule
      Under R.C. 1311.011(B)(1), a subcontractor may not obtain a lien to secure payment for work performed on a home-construction contract when the homeowner has paid the original contractor in full and payment was rendered before the homeowner received a copy of the subcontractor’s lien.
  19. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    What does Oregon's construction prompt-payment statute say about lien waivers from subcontractors and suppliers?

    An original contractor, subcontractor or material supplier that performs in accordance with a construction contract is entitled to payment from the party with whom it contracts (ORS 701.630(1)), and the seven-day pass-through duty in 701.630(2)(a) runs to a subcontractor, to a material supplier and from an original subcontractor down to the next tier. ORS 701.630(2)(b) provides that payment under subsection (2) is not required unless a subcontractor or material supplier provides a billing or invoice for the work performed or materials or products supplied in compliance with the terms of its contract, that each subcontractor or material supplier must provide an appropriate waiver of any lien for labor, equipment, services, materials or products in accordance with subcontract or purchase order terms and conditions, and that the original contractor or subcontractor may require that such lien waivers be notarized. ORS 701.620 to 701.640 do not apply to buildings subject to the Low-Rise Residential Dwelling Code, public contracts, or housing in which all or part of the dwelling units are reserved for rental to persons with income at or below 80 percent of area median household income (701.645).

    The trap

    What the lien waiver must cover is set by the subcontract or purchase order terms, not by a statutory form: Oregon's private prompt-payment sections prescribe no form of construction lien waiver, and nothing in them says whether a waiver given for a progress payment releases amounts not yet paid. No Oregon appellate decision construing ORS 701.620 to 701.645 was found, so what an 'appropriate' waiver must contain has no judicial gloss in this state. The waiver obligation is also a condition on the seven-day payment duty, not a free-standing one: 701.630(2)(b) makes payment 'not required under this subsection' unless the billing complies with the contract and the appropriate waiver is provided.

    as of 2026-09-17· reaches construction contracts only

    4 authorities

    • statuteORS 701.630enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      An original contractor, subcontractor or material supplier that performs in accordance with a construction contract is entitled to payment from the party with whom the original contractor, subcontractor or material supplier contracts.
    • statuteORS 701.630enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If a subcontractor has performed in accordance with a construction contract, and the original contractor receives payment from the owner for work performed by the subcontractor, the original contractor shall pay the subcontractor for that work no later than seven days after the original contractor receives the payment. If a material supplier has performed in accordance with a construction contract, and the original contractor receives payment from the owner for materials or products provided by the material supplier, the original contractor shall pay the material supplier for those materials and products no later than seven days after the original contractor receives the payment. An original subcontractor that receives payment under this subsection for work provided to the original subcontractor by another subcontractor, or for materials or products provided to the original subcontractor, shall pay the other subcontractor or material supplier for the work, materials or products no later than seven days after the original subcontractor receives the payment.
    • statuteORS 701.630enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Payment is not required under this subsection unless a subcontractor or material supplier provides to the original contractor or subcontractor a billing or invoice for the work performed or materials or products supplied in compliance with the terms of the contract between the parties. Each subcontractor or material supplier must provide an appropriate waiver of any lien for labor, equipment, services, materials or products in accordance with subcontract or purchase order terms and conditions. The original contractor or subcontractor may require that such waivers of lien be notarized.
    • statuteORS 701.645enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      ORS 701.620 to 701.640 do not apply to: (1) A contract for the construction, alteration, repair, maintenance, moving or demolition of a building that is subject to the Low-Rise Residential Dwelling Code; (2) A public contract under ORS 279.835 to 279.855 or ORS chapter 279A, 279B or 279C; or (3) Housing in which all or part of the dwelling units are reserved for rental to persons having an income equal to or less than 80 percent of the median household income for the area as determined by the Housing and Community Services Department.
  20. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is the up-front mechanics-lien waiver in our Rhode Island subcontract enforceable?

    No, except a written waiver executed and delivered simultaneously with or after payment. R.I. Gen. Laws § 34-28-1(b) makes a covenant in or collateral to a construction contract “purporting to bar the filing of a notice of intention or the taking of any steps to enforce a lien as set forth in this chapter … against public policy and … void and unenforceable”, and the Supreme Court has read it that way: “§ 34-28-1(b) … expressly prohibits any contractual waiver of a party’s right to file a mechanic’s lien” (Newman v. Valleywood Associates, Inc.). The same subsection then carves out the paid waiver: it “shall not preclude a requirement for a written waiver of the right to file a mechanic’s lien executed and delivered by a contractor, subcontractor, material supplier, or laborer simultaneously with or after payment for the labor performed or the materials furnished has been made”. A DIFFERENT SECTION runs the other way and is the one that decides most real disputes: under § 34-28-26 a signed subordination agreement or release “which purports to subordinate or release any lien … whether for work done or materials furnished prior to the agreement or release, or thereafter, or both, notwithstanding the fact that no consideration is given therefor, shall be enforceable according to its terms, by any other person who has changed his or her position in any way in reliance upon” it. A lienor who releases before being paid keeps only § 34-28-27’s right to “demand and receive direct payment … from the owner”.

    The trap

    The Rhode Island line is between a WAIVER OF THE RIGHT TO FILE and a RELEASE. Section 34-28-1(b) voids the first unless it is given simultaneously with or after payment; § 34-28-26 makes the second “enforceable according to its terms” with NO consideration at all, against anyone who changed position in reliance on it. Calling the closing document a release or a subordination rather than a waiver moves it out of the protective subsection entirely, and nothing in § 34-28-26 requires that the signer have been paid. Second, read § 34-28-1(b)’s own subject matter before relying on it: the ban covers work on “a building, structure, appurtenance and appliance, including moving, demolition and excavating connected therewith”, which is narrower than the lien itself in § 34-28-1(a) (“any building, canal, turnpike, railroad, or other improvement”) and narrower than the construction anti-indemnity statute § 6-34-1, which does reach a “highway, road”. Third, Newman’s footnote (“any contractual waiver”) is broader than the subsection it cites, which expressly preserves the paid waiver: serve the statute, not the footnote. Fourth, on a state or municipal job § 34-28-31 means there is no lien to waive at all (“No lien … shall attach … if the improvement is being constructed … by or for the state, or any city or town”); the substitute is the § 37-12-1 payment bond, suable under § 37-12-2 after ninety days. Fifth, an unregistered contractor “may not file a lien” in the first place (§ 5-65-4). And on a “contract for construction” a lien waiver or release is a statutory “deliverable” that “shall comply with chapter 28 of title 34” (§ 5-65-1(8)), while § 37-12-10.1(k) voids any term that “purports to waive, limit, or subvert” the retainage section it is delivered under. Two qualifications a form must not miss: § 5-65-4(b) lets “[a] court … choose not to apply this section if the court finds that to do so would result in a substantial injustice to the unregistered contractor”, so the registration bar is not absolute; and on a public job the § 37-12-1 bond is reachable by a second-tier claimant only on the written notice § 37-12-2's proviso requires within ninety days of the last labour or material.

    as of 2026-09-20· reaches construction contracts only

    17 authorities

    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 34-28-1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      purporting to bar the filing of a notice of intention or the taking of any steps to enforce a lien as set forth in this chapter is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 34-28-1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This section shall not preclude a requirement for a written waiver of the right to file a mechanic’s lien executed and delivered by a contractor, subcontractor, material supplier, or laborer simultaneously with or after payment for the labor performed or the materials furnished has been made to such contractor, subcontractor, material supplier, or laborer.
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 34-28-1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A covenant, promise, agreement of understanding in, or in connection with or collateral to, a contract or agreement relative to the construction, alteration, repair, or maintenance of a building, structure, appurtenance and appliance, including moving, demolition and excavating connected therewith
    • case874 A.2d 1286Newman v. Valleywood Associates, Inc.R.I.decided 2005read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      It is important to distinguish between a contractual waiver of the right to arbitrate a dispute, which is discussed above, from a contractual waiver of a right to file a mechanic’s lien. General Laws 1956 § 34-28-1(b) *1289 expressly prohibits any contractual waiver of a party’s right to file a mechanic’s lien.
    • case874 A.2d 1286Newman v. Valleywood Associates, Inc.R.I.decided 2005read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      To achieve this end, any contractual agreement barring the filing or enforcement of a mechanic’s hen “is against pubhc policy and is void and unenforceable.” Section 34-28-1(b).
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 34-28-26enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Any subordination agreement or release, bearing the signature of any person with authority to sign the agreement or release, or of the person who is designated in a notice of intention under § 34-28-4 as the person whose signature will bind the person filing the notice, which purports to subordinate or release any lien under § 34-28-1, 34-28-2, 34-28-3 or 34-28-7 whether for work done or materials furnished prior to the agreement or release, or thereafter, or both, notwithstanding the fact that no consideration is given therefor, shall be enforceable according to its terms, by any other person who has changed his or her position in any way in reliance upon the subordination agreement or release
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 34-28-27enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Any person entitled to any lien under § 34-28-1, 34-28-2 or 34-28-3 who releases the lien before receiving payment for the work done or materials furnished forming the basis of the lien, shall be entitled to demand and receive direct payment therefor from the owner or lessee or tenant or other person as may be obligated or permitted to make the payment on behalf of the owner or lessee or tenant, provided that the person entitled to the lien first obtains the written consent of all persons in line of privity between him or her and the owner or other person
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 34-28-31enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      No lien under § 34-28-1, 34-28-2 or 34-28-3 shall attach to any building, canal, turnpike, railroad, or other improvement, if the improvement is being constructed, erected, altered, or repaired by or for the state, or any city or town, or any subdivision or agency thereof, or to any land upon which the improvement exists, if the land is owned by the state or any city or town, or any subdivision or agency thereof, but the provisions of § 34-28-30 shall apply to buildings, canals, turnpikes, railroads, or other improvements being so constructed, erected, altered, or repaired.
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 37-12-2enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      who has not been paid in full therefor before the expiration of a period of ninety (90) days after the day on which the last of the labor was performed or furnished by him or her, or material or equipment furnished or supplied by him or her for which a claim is made, shall have the right to sue on the payment bond
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 5-65-4enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A contractor may not file a lien, file a claim with the board, or bring or maintain in any court of this state a suit or action for compensation for the performance of any work on any structure or for the breach of any contract for work on any structure that is subject to this chapter, unless the contractor was
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 5-65-1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      provided, however, that a lien waiver or release, which is a deliverable, shall comply with chapter 28 of title 34
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 37-12-10.1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A provision in a contract for construction that purports to waive, limit, or subvert this section or redefine or expand the conditions for achievement of substantial completion for payment of retainage shall be void and unenforceable.
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 34-28-32.2enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This chapter is intended to afford a liberal remedy to all who have contributed labor, material, or equipment towards adding to the value of property to which the lien attaches and should be construed accordingly.
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 6-34-1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A covenant, promise, agreement, or understanding in, or in connection with or collateral to, a contract or agreement relative to the design, planning, construction, alteration, repair, or maintenance of a building, structure, highway, road, appurtenance, and appliance, including moving, demolition, and excavating connected with a building, structure, highway, road, appurtenance, or appliance
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 5-65-4enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A court may choose not to apply this section if the court finds that to do so would result in a substantial injustice to the unregistered contractor.
    • statuteR.I. Gen. Laws § 37-12-2enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      provided, however, that any person having direct contractual relationship with a subcontractor but no contractual relationship express or implied with the contractor furnishing the payment bond shall have a right of action upon the payment bond upon giving written notice to the contractor within ninety (90) days from the date on which the person furnished or performed the last of the labor, or furnished or supplied the last of the material or equipment for which the claim is made, stating with substantial accuracy the amount claimed and the name of the party to whom the labor was furnished or performed or the material or equipment was furnished or supplied. The notice shall be served by mailing the same by certified mail, postage prepaid, in an envelope addressed to the contractor at any place he or she maintains an office, conducts his or her business, or his or her residence.
    • case874 A.2d 1286Newman v. Valleywood Associates, Inc.R.I.decided 2005read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Furthermore, the remedy provided by the Mechanics’ Lien Law is not exclusive; “[ejxcept as otherwise specified, nothing in this chapter shall be construed to limit the *1290 right of any person, whether he or she have [sic ] a valid lien hereunder or not, to remedies otherwise available to him or her under law
  21. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is this construction lien-waiver clause effective in South Dakota?

    Chapter 44-9A is not the only way a South Dakota lien can be waived, and it does not say a waiver outside it is void: it supplies ONE route, expressly “in addition to all other means presently existing under law by which such liens may be waived.” What the chapter does do is set out that route exactly, and a waiver that claims to use it must meet both of its requirements. SDCL 44-9A-1: "Liens for materials, supplies, equipment, and services furnished under construction contracts to contractors or subcontractors and arising under Title 5 or Title 44 of the South Dakota Codified Laws or by virtue of the common law of this state may be expressly waived as provided in this chapter in addition to all other means presently existing under law by which such liens may be waived." The chapter's own mechanism, under SDCL 44-9A-2, reaches "Any lien to which a person or corporation furnishing materials, supplies, equipment, and services to a contractor or subcontractor would otherwise be entitled under Title 5 or Title 44 of the South Dakota Codified Laws or by virtue of the common law of this state," and such a lien "may be waived to the extent provided in this chapter by such person or corporation by the endorsement of a joint check wherein the payees include the contractor or subcontractor and the person or corporation furnishing materials, supplies, equipment, and services and by the execution of a separate agreement of waiver between the maker of the joint check and such person or corporation." SDCL 44-9A-4 confirms the effect: "The endorsement of a joint check as provided herein and the execution of a separate written agreement of waiver... shall constitute an express waiver of all rights and claims under Title 5 and Title 44 of the South Dakota Codified Laws and the common law of this state against the owner or contractor and his surety to the extent of, and as of the date of, the joint check endorsed."

    The trap

    Chapter 44-9A's own mechanism requires TWO things together (a joint check naming both the contractor/subcontractor and the materials/services supplier as payees, AND a separate written waiver agreement between the check's maker and that supplier), so a waiver clause buried in a purchase order or general contract, without both the joint check and the separate agreement, has not used the chapter's own waiver route. SDCL 44-9A-3 adds a drafting requirement even for parties using the joint-check route: the joint check itself must carry a CONSPICUOUS provision on its reverse side referencing the separate waiver agreement and stating that the payees, by endorsing, waive their claims to the extent of the check's date and amount: a joint check without that conspicuous reverse-side language does not satisfy the chapter on its own words. Chapter 44-9A also does not displace "all other means presently existing under law" by which a lien may be waived, so a waiver executed some other way is not necessarily invalid merely because it did not follow this chapter's specific route, but no South Dakota appellate opinion applying or construing Chapter 44-9A was located, so how a court weighs a non-conforming waiver against this chapter's specific mechanism is not established here.

    as of 2026-09-21

    4 authorities

    • statuteSDCL § 44-9A-1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Liens for materials, supplies, equipment, and services furnished under construction contracts to contractors or subcontractors and arising under Title 5 or Title 44 of the South Dakota Codified Laws or by virtue of the common law of this state may be expressly waived as provided in this chapter in addition to all other means presently existing under law by which such liens may be waived.
    • statuteSDCL § 44-9A-2enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Any lien to which a person or corporation furnishing materials, supplies, equipment, and services to a contractor or subcontractor would otherwise be entitled under Title 5 or Title 44 of the South Dakota Codified Laws or by virtue of the common law of this state may be waived to the extent provided in this chapter by such person or corporation by the endorsement of a joint check wherein the payees include the contractor or subcontractor and the person or corporation furnishing materials, supplies, equipment, and services and by the execution of a separate agreement of waiver between the maker of the joint check and such person or corporation.
    • statuteSDCL § 44-9A-3enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A joint check as used for the purposes provided in this chapter must have a provision on the reverse side thereof making reference to a separate written agreement of waiver between the maker and the person or corporation furnishing materials, supplies, equipment, or services to the contractor or subcontractor. Such provision must be conspicuous and mention that the payees, by their endorsements and in consideration of the payment represented by the joint check, jointly and severally waive all claims to which they might be entitled under Title 5 and Title 44 of the South Dakota Codified Laws and the common law of South Dakota for all materials, supplies, equipment, and services supplied under a clearly identified contract to the extent of and of the date of the joint check.
    • statuteSDCL § 44-9A-4enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The endorsement of a joint check as provided herein and the execution of a separate written agreement of waiver by a person or corporation furnishing materials, supplies, equipment, and services to an owner, contractor, or a subcontractor shall constitute an express waiver of all rights and claims under Title 5 and Title 44 of the South Dakota Codified Laws and the common law of this state against the owner or contractor and his surety to the extent of, and as of the date of, the joint check endorsed.
  22. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is this custom-drafted lien waiver enforceable?

    Not as a waiver and release, if it was drafted from scratch, with two statutory exits that do not depend on form. A waiver and release given by a claimant or potential claimant is unenforceable unless it substantially complies with the applicable statutory form prescribed by § 53.284(b)-(e), and under § 53.281(a) any waiver and release of a lien or payment bond claim is unenforceable unless EXECUTED AND DELIVERED in accordance with the subchapter. § 53.282(a) then states the only ways a non-conforming statement can still bind: the claimant has actually received payment in good and sufficient funds in full for the lien or payment bond claim, or the statement is in a written original contract or subcontract for the construction, remodel or repair of a single-family house, townhouse or duplex (or related land development) and was made before labor or materials were provided. The form that applies depends on the situation: subsection (b) governs a waiver executed in exchange for or to induce a PROGRESS payment where the claimant has not yet been paid, or where a single-payee or joint-payee check is given in exchange, and requires the prescribed 'CONDITIONAL WAIVER AND RELEASE ON PROGRESS PAYMENT' language. The other three forms are not optional variants either: (c) prescribes the UNCONDITIONAL waiver on a progress payment and (e) the unconditional waiver on a final payment, and each must carry, at the top of the document in bold type at least as large as the largest type used and not smaller than 10-point, a NOTICE stating that the document waives rights unconditionally and says you have been paid, that it is prohibited for a person to require your signature if you have not been paid, and that an unpaid signer should use a conditional release form instead; (d) prescribes the CONDITIONAL waiver on a final payment. The two conditional forms (b) and (d) take effect only when the named check 'has been properly endorsed and has been paid by the bank on which it is drawn', and each tells the recipient that before relying on the document 'the recipient should verify evidence of payment to the signer'. Both progress-payment forms, conditional and unconditional, release the progress payment 'except for unpaid retention, pending modifications and changes, or other items furnished': a carve-out a reader of the headline never sees.

    The trap

    Clarity is not the test here; conformity is, and form is only one of FOUR conditions. Under § 53.281(a) the waiver and release must be executed AND DELIVERED in accordance with the subchapter, and under § 53.281(b) it is effective only if it substantially complies with a § 53.284 form, is signed by the claimant or its authorized agent, AND, for a conditional release, evidence of payment to the claimant exists. The four permutations (conditional versus unconditional, progress versus final) are not interchangeable: a conditional form is contingent on the check being endorsed and paid by the bank, which is the protection a claimant loses by signing the unconditional version early. § 53.283 goes further than form: a person may NOT require a claimant to execute an unconditional waiver for a progress or final payment unless the claimant has actually received that amount in good and sufficient funds. And § 53.286 voids, as against public policy, any contract purporting to waive the right to file or enforce a lien at all, but only 'except as provided by Section 53.282', and § 53.282 is where the advance waiver survives. Its (a) is DISJUNCTIVE: a statement purporting to waive or release a lien or payment bond claim is unenforceable UNLESS it substantially complies with a § 53.284 form, OR the claimant has actually received payment in good and sufficient funds in full, OR, and this is the one that contradicts the flat answer. The statement is in a written original contract or subcontract for the construction, remodel or repair of a single-family house, townhouse or duplex, or for land development related to one, and is made BEFORE labor or materials are provided. So on those residential categories an advance contractual lien waiver in the original contract or subcontract is enforceable, and the right question is whether the job is one of them and whether the waiver predates the work. Two edges on that exit: § 53.282(c) takes a material-only supplier (one who supplies no labor) back out of (a)(3), so a supplier's advance waiver does not stand on it; and § 53.282(b) makes filing a lien rendered unenforceable by an (a)(3) waiver a § 12.002 CPRC problem only after the owner or original contractor sends a written explanation of the basis for nonpayment, evidence of the contractual waiver and a notice of request for release to the claimant AT THE ADDRESS STATED IN THE LIEN AFFIDAVIT, and the claimant fails to release the filed affidavit on or before the 14th day after those items are sent.

    as of 2026-09-14· reaches construction contracts only

    10 authorities

    • statuteTex. Prop. Code § 53.284enacted 2012-01-01
      Show the words that state the rule
      (a) A waiver and release given by a claimant or potential claimant is unenforceable unless it substantially complies with the applicable form described by Subsections (b)-(e).
    • statuteTex. Prop. Code § 53.281enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (a) Any waiver and release of a lien or payment bond claim under this chapter is unenforceable unless a waiver and release is executed and delivered in accordance with this subchapter. (b) A waiver and release is effective to release the owner, the owner's property, the contractor, and the surety on a payment bond from claims and liens only if: (1) the waiver and release substantially complies with one of the forms prescribed by Section 53.284 ; (2) the waiver and release is signed by the claimant or the claimant's authorized agent; and (3) in the case of a conditional release, evidence of payment to the claimant exists.
    • statuteTex. Prop. Code § 53.283enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A person may not require a claimant or potential claimant to execute an unconditional waiver and release for a progress payment or final payment amount unless the claimant or potential claimant received payment in that amount in good and sufficient funds.
    • statuteTex. Prop. Code § 53.286enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Notwithstanding any other law and except as provided by Section 53.282 , any contract, agreement, or understanding purporting to waive the right to file or enforce any lien or claim created under this chapter is void as against public policy.
    • statuteTex. Prop. Code § 53.284enacted 2012-01-01
      Show the words that state the rule
      (b) If a claimant or potential claimant is required to execute a waiver and release in exchange for or to induce the payment of a progress payment and is not paid in exchange for the waiver and release or if a single payee check or joint payee check is given in exchange for the waiver and release, the waiver and release must read: "CONDITIONAL WAIVER AND RELEASE ON PROGRESS PAYMENT "Project ___________________ "Job No. ___________________ "On receipt by the signer of this document of a check from ________________ (maker of check) in the sum of $__________ payable to _____________________ (payee or payees of check) and when the check has been properly endorsed and has been paid by the bank on which it is drawn, this document becomes effective to release any mechanic's lien right, any right arising from a payment bond that complies with a state or federal statute, any common law payment bond right, any claim for payment, and any rights under any similar ordinance, rule, or statute related to claim or payment rights for persons in the signer's position that the signer has on the property of ________________ (owner) located at ______________________ (location) to the following extent: ______________________ (job description). "This release covers a progress payment for all labor, services, equipment, or materials furnished to the property or to __________________ (person with whom signer contracted) as indicated in the attached statement(s) or progress payment request(s), except for unpaid retention, pending modifications and changes, or other items furnished. "Before any recipient of this document relies on this document, the recipient should verify evidence of payment to the signer. "The signer warrants that the signer has already paid or will use the funds received from this progress payment to promptly pay in full all of the signer's laborers, subcontractors, materialmen, and suppliers for all work, materials, equipment, or services provided for or to the above referenced project in regard to the attached statement(s) or progress payment request(s).
    • statuteTex. Prop. Code § 53.284enacted 2012-01-01
      Show the words that state the rule
      (c) If a claimant or potential claimant is required to execute an unconditional waiver and release to prove the receipt of good and sufficient funds for a progress payment and the claimant or potential claimant asserts in the waiver and release that the claimant or potential claimant has been paid the progress payment, the waiver and release must: (1) contain a notice at the top of the document, printed in bold type at least as large as the largest type used in the document, but not smaller than 10-point type, that reads: "NOTICE: "This document waives rights unconditionally and states that you have been paid for giving up those rights. It is prohibited for a person to require you to sign this document if you have not been paid the payment amount set forth below. If you have not been paid, use a conditional release form."; and (2) below the notice, read: "UNCONDITIONAL WAIVER AND RELEASE ON PROGRESS PAYMENT "Project ___________________ "Job No. ___________________ "The signer of this document has been paid and has received a progress payment in the sum of $___________ for all labor, services, equipment, or materials furnished to the property or to _____________________ (person with whom signer contracted) on the property of _______________________ (owner) located at ______________________ (location) to the following extent: ______________________ (job description). The signer therefore waives and releases any mechanic's lien right, any right arising from a payment bond that complies with a state or federal statute, any common law payment bond right, any claim for payment, and any rights under any similar ordinance, rule, or statute related to claim or payment rights for persons in the signer's position that the signer has on the above referenced project to the following extent: "This release covers a progress payment for all labor, services, equipment, or materials furnished to the property or to __________________ (person with whom signer contracted) as indicated in the attached statement(s) or progress payment request(s), except for unpaid retention, pending modifications and changes, or other items furnished.
    • statuteTex. Prop. Code § 53.284enacted 2012-01-01
      Show the words that state the rule
      (d) If a claimant or potential claimant is required to execute a waiver and release in exchange for or to induce the payment of a final payment and is not paid in good and sufficient funds in exchange for the waiver and release or if a single payee check or joint payee check is given in exchange for the waiver and release, the waiver and release must read: "CONDITIONAL WAIVER AND RELEASE ON FINAL PAYMENT "Project ___________________ "Job No. ___________________ "On receipt by the signer of this document of a check from ________________ (maker of check) in the sum of $____________ payable to _____________________ (payee or payees of check) and when the check has been properly endorsed and has been paid by the bank on which it is drawn, this document becomes effective to release any mechanic's lien right, any right arising from a payment bond that complies with a state or federal statute, any common law payment bond right, any claim for payment, and any rights under any similar ordinance, rule, or statute related to claim or payment rights for persons in the signer's position that the signer has on the property of _____________________ (owner) located at ______________________ (location) to the following extent: ______________________ (job description). "This release covers the final payment to the signer for all labor, services, equipment, or materials furnished to the property or to __________________ (person with whom signer contracted). "Before any recipient of this document relies on this document, the recipient should verify evidence of payment to the signer. "The signer warrants that the signer has already paid or will use the funds received from this final payment to promptly pay in full all of the signer's laborers, subcontractors, materialmen, and suppliers for all work, materials, equipment, or services provided for or to the above referenced project up to the date of this waiver and release.
    • statuteTex. Prop. Code § 53.284enacted 2012-01-01
      Show the words that state the rule
      (e) If a claimant or potential claimant is required to execute an unconditional waiver and release to prove the receipt of good and sufficient funds for a final payment and the claimant or potential claimant asserts in the waiver and release that the claimant or potential claimant has been paid the final payment, the waiver and release must: (1) contain a notice at the top of the document, printed in bold type at least as large as the largest type used in the document, but not smaller than 10-point type, that reads: "NOTICE: "This document waives rights unconditionally and states that you have been paid for giving up those rights. It is prohibited for a person to require you to sign this document if you have not been paid the payment amount set forth below. If you have not been paid, use a conditional release form."; and (2) below the notice, read: "UNCONDITIONAL WAIVER AND RELEASE ON FINAL PAYMENT "Project ___________________ "Job No. ___________________ "The signer of this document has been paid in full for all labor, services, equipment, or materials furnished to the property or to ___________________ (person with whom signer contracted) on the property of ______________________ (owner) located at ______________________ (location) to the following extent: ______________________ (job description). The signer therefore waives and releases any mechanic's lien right
    • statuteTex. Prop. Code § 53.282enacted 2012-01-01
      Show the words that state the rule
      (a) A statement purporting to waive, release, or otherwise adversely affect a lien or payment bond claim is not enforceable and does not create an estoppel or impairment of a lien or payment bond claim unless: (1) the statement is in writing and substantially complies with a form prescribed by Section 53.284 ; (2) the claimant has actually received payment in good and sufficient funds in full for the lien or payment bond claim; or (3) the statement is: (A) in a written original contract or subcontract for the construction, remodel, or repair of a single-family house, townhouse, or duplex or for land development related to a single-family house, townhouse, or duplex; and (B) made before labor or materials are provided under the original contract or subcontract. (b) The filing of a lien rendered unenforceable by a lien waiver under Subsection (a)(3) does not violate Section 12.002 , Civil Practice and Remedies Code, unless: (1) an owner or original contractor sends a written explanation of the basis for nonpayment, evidence of the contractual waiver of lien rights, and a notice of request for release of the lien to the claimant at the claimant's address stated in the lien affidavit; and (2) the lien claimant does not release the filed lien affidavit on or before the 14th day after the date the owner or the original contractor sends the items required by Subdivision (1).
    • statuteTex. Prop. Code § 53.282enacted 2012-01-01
      Show the words that state the rule
      (c) Subsection (a)(3) does not apply to a person who supplies only material, and not labor, for the construction, remodel, or repair of a single-family house, townhouse, or duplex or for land development related to a single-family house, townhouse, or duplex.
  23. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Can a Utah construction contract waive mechanic's lien rights in advance?

    No. A right or privilege under the Preconstruction and Construction Liens chapter may not be waived or limited by contract, and a contract provision purporting to do so is void; a claimant may waive or limit a lien right only in consideration of payment as § 38-1a-802 provides (§ 38-1a-105). Under § 38-1a-802 a claimant's written consent that waives or limits its lien rights is enforceable only if the claimant executes a signed waiver and release (or a restrictive endorsement on a check in substantially the statutory form) AND receives payment of the amount identified, and for a progress payment only to the extent of the payment. A waiver and release meets the section's requirements if it is in substantially the form the section sets out for the circumstance. If payment is made by check and the check fails to clear, the waiver and release is void and the claimant's lien, bond, contract and other payment rights are unaffected.

    The trap

    On a restrictive endorsement, receiving payment means the check was presented to and paid by the institution it is drawn on, so endorsing alone releases nothing, and if the endorsement does not say whether the check is a progress or a final payment it counts as a progress payment. A waiver signed in exchange for a check that bounces is void by statute, and a progress-payment waiver releases only the amount actually paid. The statutory progress-payment form also excludes retention, pending change items, disputed claims and later-furnished items, and because a waiver is enforceable only once the claimant receives payment, a release signed before payment does not bind until the payment is received. Accord and satisfaction of a bona fide dispute, and settlement of a pending action, can still impair lien rights if in a writing signed by the claimant that specifically references the lien rights.

    as of 2026-09-17

    9 authorities

    • statuteUtah Code § 38-1a-105enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A right or privilege under this chapter may not be waived or limited by contract. A provision of a contract purporting to waive or limit a right or privilege under this chapter is void. Notwithstanding Subsection (1) , a claimant may waive or limit, in whole or in part, a lien right under this chapter in consideration of payment as provided in Section 38-1a-802
    • statuteUtah Code § 38-1a-802enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Notwithstanding Section 38-1a-105 , a claimant's written consent that waives or limits the claimant's lien rights is enforceable only if the claimant: executes a waiver and release that is signed by the claimant or the claimant's authorized agent; or for a restrictive endorsement on a check, includes a restrictive endorsement on a check that is: signed by the claimant or the claimant's authorized agent; and in substantially the same form set forth in Subsection (4)(d) ; and receives payment of the amount identified in the waiver and release or check that includes the restrictive endorsement: including payment by a joint payee check; and for a progress payment, only to the extent of the payment.
    • statuteUtah Code § 38-1a-802enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If the conditions of Subsection (3)(a) are met: the waiver and release described in Subsection (3)(a) is void; and the following will not be affected by the claimant's execution of the waiver and release: any lien; any lien right; any bond right; any contract right; or any other right to recover payment afforded to the claimant in law or equity.
    • statuteUtah Code § 38-1a-802enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Notwithstanding the language of a waiver and release described in Subsection (2) , Subsection (3)(b) applies if: the payment given in exchange for any waiver and release of lien is made by check; and the check fails to clear the depository institution on which it is drawn for any reason.
    • statuteUtah Code § 38-1a-802enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      This waiver and release applies to a progress payment for the work, materials, equipment, or a combination of work, materials, and equipment furnished by the undersigned to the Property or to the Undersigned's Customer which are the subject of the Invoice or Payment Application, but only to the extent of the Payment Amount. This waiver and release does not apply to any retention withheld; any items, modifications, or changes pending approval; disputed items and claims; or items furnished or invoiced after the Payment Period.
    • statuteUtah Code § 38-1a-802enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If the conditions of Subsection (5)(b) are met, this section does not affect the enforcement of: an accord and satisfaction regarding a bona fide dispute; or an agreement made in settlement of an action pending in any court or arbitration. Pursuant to Subsection (5)(a) , this section does not affect enforcement of an accord and satisfaction or settlement described in Subsection (5)(a) if the accord and satisfaction or settlement: is in a writing signed by the claimant; and specifically references the lien rights waived or impaired.
    • statuteUtah Code § 38-1a-802enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      As used in this section: "Check" means a payment instrument on a depository institution including: a check; a draft; an order; or other instrument. "Depository institution" is as defined in Section 7-1-103 . "Receives payment" means, in the case of a restrictive endorsement, a payee has endorsed a check and the check is presented to and paid by the depository institution on which it is drawn.
    • statuteUtah Code § 38-1a-802enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A waiver and release given by a claimant meets the requirements of this section if it is in substantially the form provided in this Subsection (4) for the circumstance provided in this Subsection (4) .
    • statuteUtah Code § 38-1a-802enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      If using a restrictive endorsement under Subsection (4)(d) , the person preparing the check shall indicate whether the check is for a progress payment or a final payment by circling the word "progress" if the check is for a progress payment, or the word "final" if the check is for a final payment. If a restrictive endorsement does not indicate whether the check is for a progress payment or a final payment, it is considered to be for a progress payment.
  24. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is the up-front lien waiver in our Virginia subcontract enforceable?

    No, if it was signed before the work. Va. Code § 43-3(C) provides that any right to file or enforce a mechanics' lien "may be waived in whole or in part at any time by any person entitled to such lien, except that a general contractor, subcontractor, lower-tier subcontractor, or material supplier may not waive or diminish his lien rights in a contract in advance of furnishing any labor, services, or materials", and "A provision that waives or diminishes a general contractor's, subcontractor's, lower-tier subcontractor's, or material supplier's lien rights in a contract executed prior to providing any labor, services, or materials is null and void." The companion section does the same for two other rights: a subcontractor as defined in § 43-1, a lower-tier subcontractor or a material supplier "may not waive or diminish his right to assert payment bond claims or his right to assert claims for demonstrated additional costs in a contract in advance of furnishing any labor, services, or materials", and such a provision executed beforehand "is null and void" (§ 11-4.1:1). On a public project, "Any waiver of the right to sue on the payment bond required by this section shall be void unless it is in writing, signed by the person whose right is waived, and executed after such person has performed labor or furnished material in accordance with the contract documents" (§ 2.2-4341(D)). A waiver given AFTER the work still has to clear the older common-law requirements, stated in cases that were themselves about advance waivers, First American Bank having enforced a pre-work Base Agreement waiver that § 43-3(C) would now void: it "must be express, or, if it is implied, it must be established by clear and convincing evidence" (First American Bank, quoting McMerit), and "the general rule is that an agreement to waive or release a mechanic's lien must be supported by consideration to be valid and binding" (United Masonry).

    The trap

    The prohibition is on advance waiver, not on waiver, so the answer turns on WHEN the paper was signed rather than on how it is worded, and it protects only the four categories the statute names. Two further Virginia traps: § 43-3(A) sets the lien threshold at labour or materials "of the value of $150 or more, including the reasonable rental or use value of equipment"; and § 43-3(D) takes the lien away from a person who performs labour "without a valid license or certificate issued by the Board for Contractors pursuant to Chapter 11 (§ 54.1-1100 et seq.) of Title 54.1, or without the proper class of license for the value of the work to be performed", so an unlicensed or under-classed subcontractor has nothing to waive in the first place. Two more limits from the same sections. Section 43-3(A) gives no lien at all for repairs or improvements to an existing structure "unless such repairs or improvements were ordered or authorized by the owner, or his agent", so a subcontractor on a renovation the owner never authorised has no lien to waive. And on a public project the bond right the waiver rule protects is itself gated: a claimant who contracted with a subcontractor but not with the prime may sue on the bond only after written notice to the contractor within 90 days of its last labour or materials, except for sums withheld as retainages, which the subsection's time limits do not reach, and any action on the bond must be brought within one year of the claimant's last work (§ 2.2-4341(B), (C)): a post-work waiver signed after those windows close is a waiver of nothing. Both Virginia cases on waiver language predate the 2015 prohibition. We hold no opinion citing § 43-3(C) after 2000 and none citing § 11-4.1:1 at all.

    as of 2026-09-20· reaches construction contracts only

    12 authorities

    • statuteVa. Code § 43-3enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Any right to file or enforce any mechanics' lien granted hereunder may be waived in whole or in part at any time by any person entitled to such lien, except that a general contractor, subcontractor, lower-tier subcontractor, or material supplier may not waive or diminish his lien rights in a contract in advance of furnishing any labor, services, or materials. A provision that waives or diminishes a general contractor's, subcontractor's, lower-tier subcontractor's, or material supplier's lien rights in a contract executed prior to providing any labor, services, or materials is null and void.
    • statuteVa. Code § 43-3enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A person who performs labor without a valid license or certificate issued by the Board for Contractors pursuant to Chapter 11 (§ 54.1-1100 et seq.) of Title 54.1, or without the proper class of license for the value of the work to be performed, when such a license or certificate is required by law for the labor performed shall not be entitled to a lien pursuant to this section.
    • statuteVa. Code § 11-4.1:1enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A subcontractor as defined in § 43-1 , lower-tier subcontractor, or material supplier may not waive or diminish his right to assert payment bond claims or his right to assert claims for demonstrated additional costs in a contract in advance of furnishing any labor, services, or materials. A provision that waives or diminishes a subcontractor's, lower-tier subcontractor's, or material supplier's right to assert payment bond claims or his right to assert claims for demonstrated additional costs in a contract executed prior to providing any labor, services, or materials is null and void.
    • statuteVa. Code § 2.2-4341enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      Any waiver of the right to sue on the payment bond required by this section shall be void unless it is in writing, signed by the person whose right is waived, and executed after such person has performed labor or furnished material in accordance with the contract documents.
    • case259 Va. 60First American Bank of Virginia v. J.S.C. Concrete Construction, Inc.Va.decided 2000read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Such a waiver "must be express, or, if it is implied, it must be established by clear and convincing evidence."
    • case233 Va. 476United Masonry, Inc. of Virginia v. Riggs National BankVa.decided 1987read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Although a person entitled to a mechanic’s lien may waive that right in whole or part, Code § 43-3(c), the general rule is that an agreement to waive or release a mechanic’s lien must be supported by consideration to be valid and binding. See Walker & LaBerge Co. v. Bank, 206 Va. 683, 688, 692 , 146 S.E.2d 239, 243, 245-46 (1966). See generally, 53 Am. Jur.2d Mech. Liens § 292 (1970 & Supp. 1986); 57 C.J.S. Mech. Liens § 223 (1948 & Supp. 1986). Sufficient consideration exists if the promisee is induced by the waiver to do something that he is not legally bound to do or refrains from doing anything he has a legal right to do, or if the promisee acts in reliance upon the waiver to his detriment.
    • statuteVa. Code § 43-3enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      But when the claim is for repairs or improvements to existing structures only, no lien shall attach to the property repaired or improved unless such repairs or improvements were ordered or authorized by the owner, or his agent.
    • statuteVa. Code § 2.2-4341enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      B. Any claimant who has a direct contractual relationship with any subcontractor but who has no contractual relationship, express or implied, with the contractor, may bring an action on the contractor's payment bond only if he has given written notice to the contractor within 90 days from the day on which the claimant performed the last of the labor or furnished the last of the materials for which he claims payment, stating with substantial accuracy the amount claimed and the name of the person for whom the work was performed or to whom the material was furnished. Notice to the contractor shall be served by registered or certified mail, postage prepaid, in an envelope addressed to such contractor at any place where his office is regularly maintained for the transaction of business. Claims for sums withheld as retainages with respect to labor performed or materials furnished, shall not be subject to the time limitations stated in this subsection.
    • statuteVa. Code § 2.2-4341enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      C. Any action on a payment bond shall be brought within one year after the day on which the person bringing such action last performed labor or last furnished or supplied materials.
    • statuteVa. Code § 43-3enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      All persons performing labor or furnishing materials of the value of $150 or more, including the reasonable rental or use value of equipment, for the construction, removal, repair or improvement of any building or structure permanently annexed to the freehold, and all persons performing any labor or furnishing materials of like value for the construction of any railroad, shall have a lien, if perfected as hereinafter provided, upon such building or structure, and so much land therewith as shall be necessary for the convenient use and enjoyment thereof, and upon such railroad and franchises for the work done and materials furnished, subject to the provisions of § 43-20 .
    • case259 Va. 60First American Bank of Virginia v. J.S.C. Concrete Construction, Inc.Va.decided 2000read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Consequently, we hold that the trial court erred in refusing to rule that JSC waived its rights to file mechanic's liens.
    • case233 Va. 476United Masonry, Inc. of Virginia v. Riggs National BankVa.decided 1987read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      The cash payments that United Masonry received, coupled with the inducement to Riggs and Chicago Title to continue construction advances, constituted sufficient consideration for the waivers.
  25. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Can a Washington contract make a contractor or subcontractor give up its payment protections in advance?

    On public works, no. RCW 39.04.900 provides that the rights provided in chapter 223, Laws of 1992 may not be waived by the parties and that a contract provision providing for waiver of those rights is void as against public policy, and that the chapter is to be liberally construed. RCW 39.04.901 makes RCW 39.76.011, 60.28.011, 60.28.021, 60.28.051, 39.04.250 and 39.04.900 applicable to all public works contracts entered into on or after September 1, 1992. Among those sections, RCW 60.28.011(2) gives every person performing labor or furnishing supplies toward completion of a public improvement contract a lien upon the retainage the public body reserves, with notice of the lien due within forty-five days of completion of the contract work. The retainage those liens attach to is bounded: public improvement contracts "must provide, and public bodies must reserve, a contract retainage not to exceed five percent of the moneys earned by the contractor as a trust fund" for claims under the contract and for state taxes (RCW 60.28.011(1)(a)). A contractor may instead submit a bond for all or any portion of that retainage, and the bond "and any proceeds therefrom are subject to all claims and liens and in the same manner and priority as set forth for retained percentages in this chapter" (RCW 60.28.011(6)). The release clock is in subsection (3): the contractor "at any time may request the contract retainage be reduced to one hundred percent of the value of the work remaining on the project"; after completion of all contract work other than landscaping it may request release, and sixty days later the public body must release and pay in full "(other than continuing retention of five percent of the moneys earned for landscaping)"; and sixty days after completion of all contract work the public body must release and pay in full, subject to chapter 39.12 RCW and this chapter (RCW 60.28.011(3)).

    The trap

    This is a PUBLIC WORKS rule. Washington's private construction lien chapter, RCW 60.04, contains no provision on advance waiver of lien rights (all thirty-three of its sections carry no "waiv" at all), so the chapter's only word on giving up a private lien is RCW 60.04.191: taking a promissory note "does not discharge the lien therefor, unless expressly received as payment and so specified therein". What the code does show is that the legislature speaks to the question expressly when it means to, and both ways: a contract "may not waive or require an employee to waive the right to a wage lien under this chapter" and a provision that does "is void as against the public policy of this state" (RCW 60.90.110), while a commercial-real-estate owner "may request that a broker waive the rights to a lien under this chapter, and such a waiver contained in the commission agreement signed by the broker is effective" (RCW 60.42.010(9)). Note also that where a public improvement contract is "funded in whole or in part by federal transportation funds" there is no retainage for the lien to attach to: those contracts "must rely upon the contract bond as referred to in chapter 39.08 RCW", and that bond "must remain in full force and effect until, at a minimum, all claims filed in compliance with chapter 39.08 RCW are resolved" (RCW 60.28.011(1)(b)).

    as of 2026-09-16

    13 authorities

    • statuteRCW 39.04.900enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (1) The rights provided in chapter 223, Laws of 1992 may not be waived by the parties and a contract provision that provides for waiver of the rights provided in chapter 223, Laws of 1992 is void as against public policy. (2) Chapter 223, Laws of 1992 is to be liberally construed to provide security for all parties intended to be protected by its provisions.
    • statuteRCW 39.04.901enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      RCW 39.76.011, 60.28.011, 60.28.021, 60.28.051, 39.04.250, and 39.04.900 are applicable to all public works contracts entered into on or after September 1, 1992, relating to the construction of any work of improvement.
    • statuteRCW 60.28.011enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (2) Every person performing labor or furnishing supplies toward the completion of a public improvement contract has a lien upon moneys reserved by a public body under the provisions of a public improvement contract. However, the notice of the lien of the claimant must be given within forty-five days of completion of the contract work, and in the manner provided in RCW 39.08.030.
    • statuteRCW 60.28.011enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (1)(a) Except as provided in (b) of this subsection, public improvement contracts must provide, and public bodies must reserve, a contract retainage not to exceed five percent of the moneys earned by the contractor as a trust fund for the protection and payment of: (i) The claims of any person arising under the contract; and (ii) the state with respect to taxes, increases, and penalties imposed pursuant to Titles 50, 51, and 82 RCW which may be due from such contractor.
    • statuteRCW 60.28.011enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (b) Public improvement contracts funded in whole or in part by federal transportation funds must rely upon the contract bond as referred to in chapter 39.08 RCW for the protection and payment of: (i) The claims of any person or persons arising under the contract to the extent such claims are provided for in RCW 39.08.010; and (ii) the state with respect to taxes, increases, and penalties incurred on the public improvement project under Titles 50, 51, and 82 RCW which may be due. The contract bond must remain in full force and effect until, at a minimum, all claims filed in compliance with chapter 39.08 RCW are resolved.
    • statuteRCW 60.28.011enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (3) The contractor at any time may request the contract retainage be reduced to one hundred percent of the value of the work remaining on the project. (a) After completion of all contract work other than landscaping, the contractor may request that the public body release and pay in full the amounts retained during the performance of the contract, and sixty days thereafter the public body must release and pay in full the amounts retained (other than continuing retention of five percent of the moneys earned for landscaping) subject to the provisions of chapter 39.12 RCW and this chapter. (b) Sixty days after completion of all contract work the public body must release and pay in full the amounts retained during the performance of the contract subject to the provisions of chapter 39.12 RCW and this chapter.
    • statuteRCW 60.90.110enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      A contract between an employer and employee may not waive or require an employee to waive the right to a wage lien under this chapter. A provision of a contract made in violation of this section is void as against the public policy of this state.
    • statuteRCW 60.42.010enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (9) An owner of commercial real estate may request that a broker waive the rights to a lien under this chapter, and such a waiver contained in the commission agreement signed by the broker is effective to waive the broker's rights to a lien under this chapter.
    • statuteRCW 60.28.011enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (6) A contractor may submit a bond for all or any portion of the contract retainage in a form acceptable to the public body and from an authorized surety insurer. The public body may require that the authorized surety have a minimum A.M. Best financial strength rating so long as that minimum rating does not exceed A-. The public body must comply with the provisions of RCW 48.28.010. At any time prior to final formal acceptance of the project, a subcontractor may request the contractor to submit a bond to the public owner for that portion of the contractor's retainage pertaining to the subcontractor in a form acceptable to the public body and from a bonding company meeting standards established by the public body. The contractor may withhold the subcontractor's portion of the bond premium. Within thirty days of receipt of the request, the contractor shall provide and the public body shall accept a bond meeting these requirements unless the public body can demonstrate good cause for refusing to accept it, the bond is not commercially available, or the subcontractor refuses to pay the subcontractor's portion of the bond premium and to provide the contractor with a like bond. The contractor's bond and any proceeds therefrom are subject to all claims and liens and in the same manner and priority as set forth for retained percentages in this chapter. The public body must release the bonded portion of the retained funds to the contractor within thirty days of accepting the bond from the contractor. Whenever a public body accepts a bond in lieu of retained funds from a contractor, the contractor must accept like bonds from any subcontractors or suppliers from which the contractor has retained funds. The contractor must then release the funds retained from the subcontractor or supplier to the subcontractor or supplier within thirty days of accepting the bond from the subcontractor or supplier.
    • statuteRCW 60.28.011enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (10) Contracts on projects funded in whole or in part by farmers home administration and subject to farmers home administration regulations are not subject to subsections (1) through (9) of this section.
    • statuteRCW 60.28.011enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (11) This subsection applies only to a public body that has contracted for the construction of a facility using the general contractor/construction manager procedure, as defined under RCW 39.10.210. If the work performed by a subcontractor on the project has been completed within the first half of the time provided in the general contractor/construction manager contract for completing the work, the public body may accept the completion of the subcontract. The public body must give public notice of this acceptance. After a forty-five day period for giving notice of liens, and compliance with the retainage release procedures in RCW 60.28.021, the public body may release that portion of the retained funds associated with the subcontract. Claims against the retained funds after the forty-five day period are not valid.
    • statuteRCW 60.28.011enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      (12) The definitions in this subsection apply throughout this section unless the context clearly requires otherwise. (a) "Contract retainage" means an amount reserved by a public body from the moneys earned by a person under a public improvement contract. (b) "Person" means a person or persons, mechanic, subcontractor, or materialperson who performs labor or provides materials for a public improvement contract, and any other person who supplies the person with provisions or supplies for the carrying on of a public improvement contract. (c) "Public body" means the state, or a county, city, town, district, board, or other public body. (d) "Public improvement contract" means a contract for public improvements or work, other than for professional services, or a work order as defined in RCW 39.10.210.
    • statuteRCW 60.04.191enactment date not established
      Show the words that state the rule
      The taking of a promissory note or other evidence of indebtedness for any labor, professional services, material, or equipment furnished for which a lien is created by this chapter does not discharge the lien therefor, unless expressly received as payment and so specified therein. Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to impair or affect the right of any person to whom any debt may be due for the furnishing of labor, professional services, material, or equipment to maintain a personal action to recover the debt against any person liable therefor. [ 1991 c 281 s 19.]
  26. read at the 2026-10-03 bar

    Is the advance lien-waiver requirement in our subcontract enforceable, and does signing a waiver before payment give up the lien?

    The clause is void and the waiver is not. The Court of Appeals in Tri-State Mechanical recorded that Wis. Stat. § 779.135(1) voids a provision that requires a subcontractor to waive its right to a construction lien before it can get paid, and that the policy behind the statute was to ensure that contractors and subcontractors were paid for their work before they were required to produce a lien waiver. But the court held that the waiver the subcontractor actually furnished was not void as a result: Wis. Stat. § 779.05(1) allows a subcontractor who has signed a contract containing a lien waiver provision to refuse to furnish a waiver unless paid in full for the work or material to which the waiver relates, so the legislature gave the subcontractor a choice, and a subcontractor who tenders the waiver before payment has made it. Section 779.05(1) is not only a right to refuse, and the rest of it runs the other way: a waiver binds whether or not consideration was paid and whether it was signed before or after the labour or material was furnished, any ambiguity in it is construed against the person who signed it, and it is deemed to waive all lien rights for all labour and materials furnished at any time for that improvement except to the extent the document specifically and expressly limits the waiver to a particular portion. Those last words are where the drafting lives: the Supreme Court of Wisconsin held in Great Lakes Excavating that a waiver whose face specifically and expressly restricted it to the particular portion of the work the signer had actually been paid for did limit the waiver, and it reversed the court of appeals.

    The trap

    That is the trap in one sentence: voiding the clause does not undo the waiver. Jones argued that reading § 779.135(1) this way places an unreasonable level of legal sophistication on subcontractors, and the court answered that every person, sophisticated or otherwise, is presumed to know the law. A subcontractor in Wisconsin therefore has to act on the void clause at the moment it is asked for a waiver, not litigate about it afterwards, and the owner's reliance on the waiver is not what the analysis turns on. Two things the void clause does not take away, and one it does not give back. A furnished waiver is a waiver of lien rights only, and not of any contract rights the claimant otherwise has. But the fallback against the owner is narrow: Tri-State Mechanical affirmed the judgment against the subcontractor and held its unjust-enrichment claim failed as a matter of law, because the owner had already paid the prime contractor the contract price in full plus excess costs.

    as of 2026-09-17· reaches construction contracts only

    13 authorities

    • case2004 WI App 100Tri-State Mechanical, Inc. v. Northland CollegeWis. Ct. App.decided 2004read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      We also agree with Jones' assertion that the policy behind the statute was to ensure that contractors and subcontractors were paid for their work before they were required to produce a lien waiver.
    • case2004 WI App 100Tri-State Mechanical, Inc. v. Northland CollegeWis. Ct. App.decided 2004read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      However, we do not agree that the construction lien waiver filed by Jones is consequently void. Wisconsin Stat. § 779.05(1) specifically allows a subcontractor who has signed a contract containing a lien waiver provision to "refuse to furnish a waiver unless paid in full for the work or material to which the waiver relates."
    • case2004 WI App 100Tri-State Mechanical, Inc. v. Northland CollegeWis. Ct. App.decided 2004read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      However, as a general proposition, every person, sophisticated or otherwise, is presumed to know the law.
    • case2004 WI App 100Tri-State Mechanical, Inc. v. Northland CollegeWis. Ct. App.decided 2004read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Jones correctly indicates that Wis. Stat. § 779.135 (1) voids a provision that requires a subcontractor to waive its right to a construction lien before it *477 can get paid.
    • case2004 WI App 100Tri-State Mechanical, Inc. v. Northland CollegeWis. Ct. App.decided 2004read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Wisconsin Stat. § 779.135 states in relevant part: The following provisions in contracts for the improvement of land in this state are void: (I) Provisions requiring a contractor, subcontractor or material supplier to waive his or her right to a construction hen or to a claim against a payment bond before he or she has been paid for the labor or materials or both that he or she furnished.
    • case2004 WI App 100Tri-State Mechanical, Inc. v. Northland CollegeWis. Ct. App.decided 2004read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Thus, the legislature has provided a subcontractor facing a void construction lien waiver contract provision with a choice: it can either tender a lien *478 waiver prior to being paid or refuse to do so until it is paid. By giving the subcontractor a choice, the legislature has essentially made a policy decision that endorses whatever course of action the subcontractor takes. Here, Jones submitted a construction lien waiver before being paid notwithstanding the void contract waiver provision. In light of § 779.05(1), Jones' construction lien waiver is valid.
    • case2004 WI App 100Tri-State Mechanical, Inc. v. Northland CollegeWis. Ct. App.decided 2004read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Jones argues this conclusion places an unreasonable level of legal sophistication on subcontractors and assumes Jones knew it could refuse to comply with a void contract provision.
    • case2004 WI App 100Tri-State Mechanical, Inc. v. Northland CollegeWis. Ct. App.decided 2004read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      We reject Jones' invitation to supplement the statute with an "innocent party" requirement because this is a matter for legislative action.
    • case2004 WI App 100Tri-State Mechanical, Inc. v. Northland CollegeWis. Ct. App.decided 2004read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Wisconsin Stat. § 779.05(1) reads in full: Any document signed by a lien claimant or potential claimant and purporting to be a waiver of construction lien rights under this subchapter, is valid and binding as a waiver whether or not consideration was paid therefor and whether the document was signed before or after the labor or material was furnished or contracted for. Any ambiguity in such document shall be construed against the person signing it. Any waiver document shall be deemed to waive all lien rights of the signer for all labor and materials furnished or to be furnished by the claimant at any time for the improvement to which the waiver relates, except to the extent that the document specifically and expressly limits the waiver to apply to a particular portion of such labor and materials: A lien claimant or potential lien claimant of whom a waiver is requested is entitled to refuse to furnish a waiver unless paid in full for the work or material to which the waiver relates. A waiver furnished is a waiver of hen rights only, and not of any contract rights of the claimant otherwise existing.
    • case2004 WI App 100Tri-State Mechanical, Inc. v. Northland CollegeWis. Ct. App.decided 2004read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Jones argues the trial court erred by concluding Jones (1) tendered a valid construction lien waiver and (2) could not recover the reasonable value of its services on an unjust enrichment theory. We affirm the judgment.
    • case2004 WI App 100Tri-State Mechanical, Inc. v. Northland CollegeWis. Ct. App.decided 2004read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Here, it is unrefuted that Northland paid Tomlinson the contract price plus excess costs. Thus, Northland has fully paid for the benefits it received. Therefore, because Jones' unjust enrichment claim fails as a matter of law, the trial court did not erroneously exercise its discretion by denying Jones equitable relief.
    • case2022 WI 44Great Lakes Excavating, Inc. v. Dollar Tree Stores, Inc.Wis.decided 2022read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      Construction liens can be waived under Wis. Stat. § 779.05(1). That statute provides in relevant part: Any waiver document shall be deemed to waive all lien rights of the signer for all labor, services, materials, plans, or specifications performed, furnished, or procured, or to be performed, furnished, or procured, by the claimant at any time for the improvement to which the waiver relates, except to the extent that the document specifically and expressly limits the waiver to apply to a particular portion of such labor, services, materials, plans, or specifications. The statute further directs that "[a]ny ambiguity in such document shall be construed against the person signing it.
    • case2022 WI 44Great Lakes Excavating, Inc. v. Dollar Tree Stores, Inc.Wis.decided 2022read it at the source ↗
      Show the words that state the rule
      The construction lien waiver document on its face satisfies the statutory requirements of Wis. Stat. § 779.05(1) necessary to limit the waiver of Great Lakes' lien rights. The document "specifically and expressly" restricts the lien waiver to "a particular portion of such labor, services, materials, plans, or specifications"——the $33,448 received in consideration of the waiver. By the Court.—The decision of the court of appeals is reversed, and the cause is remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.